I love my old Volkswagen Sharan - should I replace it with the new model or with a Ford Galaxy?

I wrote to you about five years ago when I had just got my latest 2005 Volkswagen Sharan 1.9 SE diesel company car. This was my third. Like a lot of companies at the moment we are making our vehicles last a couple of years longer. Well, I know it's a really old design but I still love this car, it now has 237,000 on the clock and still knocks along at a good rate. It runs probably over half full on weight with samples, files, has had a new clutch/flywheel at around 190,000 and new turbo at 160,000 which seems about normal with these. It gets serviced every 10,000. I hope to move up to a new model or a Galaxy sometime next year, but I would still have another of these. It's so comfortable to drive all over the country - I only ever had a breakdown on one 10 years ago when the fan belt came off. Bit of a waffle I know, but a great old car.

Asked on 8 November 2010 by CB, Altrincham

Answered by Honest John
That's a real accolade for the old shape Sharan. My taxi driver gets nothing like that sort of life out of his DMFs but he is a quick, no nonsense driver. Does things I'd never dream of doing. As well as the new Galaxy you might like to consider this: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road tests/seat/alhambra-2010
Similar questions
Two months ago my Volkswagen Sharan left me, following a road accident and insurance write-off. It was a 1998 1.9 turbodiesel (110bhp) SE. It had done 239,000 miles and though worn was still lively with...
I've lost the use of a company car, have never bought a used car before and I was thinking of spending £1000 - £2000 on a car to get me 10 miles each way to work and other very short trips. My biggest...
Our Volkswagen Golf is coming to the end of its life after over 170,000 trouble-free miles and we'd like some advice on getting a new MPV. Whatever we buy we want to keep for another 10 years at least....
Related models
Good to drive and comfortable. Versatile with foldaway seats. Generally good quality. Diesel automatic option. Plenty of room in all back seats.
Strong yet frugal diesel engines. Clever use of space inside with integrated child seats. Standard DAB digital radio. Practical and large sliding rear side door.
Proper seven-seat practicality which is more than you can say for most SUVs, practical and spacious even with all seven seats occupied, sliding rear doors are a real boon especially the electric versions.

Ask Honest John

Value my car