Ask a Question

All belts and whistles

I usually change my car every three years. Now that I've retired I intend to buy a new diesel saloon and keep it for eight to ten years. My choices are: Mercedes E class, Jaguar XF, or Audi A5. In your opinion are there build quality, or any other problems, with these makes that would appear over this time frame? Although I don't garage my car, I wash and polish it regularly and have it serviced at a franchised dealer. My annual mileage is 9,000. May I have your thoughts, please?

Asked on by

I can't work out why you need as diesel for 9,000 miles a year. But of the cars on your list (I think you mean Audi A6), the latest Jag XF S with the 275PS version of the 3.0 diesel engine is by far the most rewarding (and I am including the new MB E Class here). You can drive it quickly or slowly or both and it's still fantastic. But the engine is held together with a timing belt and this will need to be replaced during 8-10 years ownership.

Honest John recommends carwow – find and buy your perfect car, in just a few clicks

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I have owned a Jaguar S Type from new since October 2003 and am now considering changing to a new XF Premium Luxury 3.0 diesel. I have never thought Diesel before but a salesman tells me that 9 out of...
I currently drive a VW Golf 1.9TDi Sport 56 plate. It's on a PCP contract and is due for renewal in November 09. I will probably pay the GMFV of £5,800 and use that as a deposit to lower the payments on...
Need new car to replace Peugeot 207SW 1.6 Sport Got two Volkswagen Golfs to choose from, a 100 mile pre-reg GT estate diesel (150) for £20k with 3 yrs free servicing OR a brand new GT estate with 150...

Ask Honest John

Value my car