Should I replace by 2.0-litre SUV with a smaller engined model?

I have a Tiguan 2013, which I would like to update. I went to a Volkswagen garage yesterday and said I wanted a used 2.0-litre 4x4. They told me I would have to have an automatic but I don't feel confident driving an auto. I have a 2.0-litre now but they tried to tell me to have a 1.5. What do you think?

Asked on 1 July 2020 by Wendy

Answered by Andrew Brady
How many miles do you drive each year? There's no point getting a diesel unless you cover lots of miles (more than 12k a year), mainly on the motorway - or, perhaps, if you need to tow something. There is a 2.0-litre petrol but it's thirsty. The 1.5-litre will suit most drivers very well. Like most manufacturers, Volkswagen is offering smaller, turbocharged petrol engines. These are usually a lot more powerful than you'd expect considering their small capacity.
Similar questions
My daughter is waiting to collect a used 2017 Kia Sportage from a Kia dealership. Your articles have often recommend drivers using Shell V power fuel. Will my daughter gain the same benefits from super...
Why are garages reluctant to carry out a turbo replacement when under an insurance backed warranty?
What would you recommend with a really good low bottom gear and hill-climbing ability from the budget Greek island hire car range? Is a Fiat Panda likely to hold the old Italian tradition of very low ratio...
Related models
Comfortable, spacious and supremely practical. Refined diesel engines. Plenty of modern technology.

Ask Honest John

Value my car