Take your pick-up

I need to change my 2007 VW Touareg for a pick-up truck. What in your opinion is the best, most car-like pick up? It has to be automatic, have all the toys (at least as options), be relaxing and smooth to drive - I've looked at the usual L200, Hilux and Navara but there are so many different specs of each, I’m not really sure of what to look at further.

Asked on 22 May 2010 by V.S., via e-mail

Answered by Honest John
None. Not one is "smooth to drive" because they are all trucks with leaf sprung rigid back axles capable of carrying at least one tonne. So they all bounce about a bit and crash over speed humps. But the fastest is the new Nissan Navara with an all-new 235PS 3.0 litre 65 degree V6 diesel that it shares with the Infiniti EX30d and Renault Laguna coupe. Auto is optional. My personal preference is for Isuzu D Max (Rodeo) and Chevrolet Colorado because they have amiable four cylinder chain-cam diesel engines and the best transmissions (I've got one of each). L200s handle best. HiLux are still all belt cam.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
At present I own a 206 plate Nissan X-Trail Aventura DCI, 4WD, six-speed gearbox. This is my private car and as I own my own limited company. I now wish to change to a company vehicle. I really enjoy the...
I have 2005 Nissan Navara for towing a 2.5 ton trailer. I find the leg room very small, the ride harsh and the rear seats unusable. Can you recomend any vehicles that can replace the Navara? Budget £8000-...
I am considering trading in my Autotrail Cheyenne motorhome and unused car (2004 Mercedes C270 Estate) and going back to towing a caravan with a new towcar. I don't actually do that many miles per annum...
Related models
Useful rear hinged rear doors on crew cab, developed alongside Pathfinder, one of the most refined 2005 pick-ups.
Luxurious, safe, accomplished 4x4. Comfortable on road, very capable off it. V10 TDI is astonishing, 2.5 TDI and 3.0 TDI the sensible choices.

Ask Honest John

Value my car