What practical and cheap to run car do you suggest to replace my ageing RAV4?

I need to replace my three-door Toyota RAV4 as I need more space and five doors. I went for the RAV4 as I live in rural Cumbria and floods/snow are likely. I do around 12,000 miles/yr and am thinking diesel to reduced fuel costs. Dogs and grandchildren need transporting so I have looked at Skoda Yeti, Skoda Roomster and Jeep Renegade.

Would 2WD be fine if I put better tyres on or should I stick with 4WD? I have a budget of up to £10000 max and my main priority is to cut running costs (fuel and tax) and have enough room for a dog, pushchair, hay bales etc (not all at once!)

Asked on 8 January 2020 by barbara schindler

Answered by Andrew Brady
A four-wheel-drive will be thirstier than a front-wheel-drive model and I think you'd be surprised at the difference a set of winter tyres makes in wintry conditions. I'd look for a two-wheel-drive crossover like a Suzuki Vitara or, if you need more space, a Kia Sportage. We normally recommend diesels for people who cover more than 12,000 miles a year, so your mileage is borderline. If most of your journeys are short and you rarely drive at motorway speeds for extended periods, a petrol will make more sense.
Similar questions
I have 2 teenage girls and need to trade in my small Fiat for something which is big enough to put a tent and some paddleboards in the boot. It also needs to be easy to park. I don’t care two hoots about...
I need to buy my wife a family car that will cope with two children under two years old and all the paraphernalia that goes with them, including a double buggy. We probably drive less than 10000 miles...
My son is a drummer in a band and struggles getting all his kit into his current Skoda Fabia. Could you recommend an SUV that would be fairly economic to run (low tax and good fuel) if there is such a...
Related models
Very good to drive and comfortable. Lots of interior space. Five star Euro NCAP rating. Relatively economical. Excellent 1.0 BoosterJet engines.
One of the best crossovers on the market, well-equipped, seven-year warranty, practical and spacious.


Value my car