Is your car your pride and joy, or are you ready for a change? Let us know and you could win a £300 John Lewis voucher | No thanks

Logbook and Payday Loans: The dangers

Published 03 May 2013

Logbook and payday loans have grown in prominence and popularity in the past five years as lending from mainstream lenders contracted.

If you have a poor credit history the options for credit are far more limited and instant cash from logbook or payday loan lender may seem an attractive option. But both need to be handled with extreme care.


What is a logbook loan?

This is a loan that is secured against your car. Often the loans are available to anyone who owns a car and no credit checks are carried out. They offer a percentage of the trade value of your vehicle. It means almost immeidate access to cash, but at a price.  

In a similar fashion to a pawnbroker, the lender will keep hold of the improtant documents associated with the car including the V5 (hence the name 'logbook loans'). You will then sign a credit agreement and 'bill of sale' that will give temporary ownership to the lender. What that means is that if you can't keep up your repayments, it will be carted ff to auction. If the sale proceeds do not cover the value of the outstanding loan, you will still need to make repayments.

The interest charges can be upwards of 400% APR.


What is a payday loan?

These loans are essentially advances on your salary to cover short term cashflow problems. You take out a loan of a up to around £1000 and within 28 days you will be expected to have paid it back. The cash is immediately available and no credit check checks are carried out.

The APR on these loans is often astronomical and seeing a representative 1700% APR is not unusual. The lenders will argue that using APR as a guide is unfair as these are short-term loans. But, they remain an expensive way of borrowing money. Many lenders charge £25 per £100 that you borrow. That means that is you borrow £500, you'd have to repay £625.

Where these loans are particularly controversial is how they encourage customers to roll their balances over to the following month ... and more. All the time the interest charges increase.

What -happens


Investigations by the OFT

High APRs and less than transparent processes have attracted the attention of The Office of Fair Trading. It's far from pleased with the conduct of these types of lenders. March 2013 saw the OFT announce that it's giving the leading 50 payday lenders (accounting for 90 per cent of the payday market) 12 weeks to change their business practices or risk losing their licences. It uncovered evidence of widespread irresponsible lending and failure to comply with the standards required of them.

At the same time it announced that it was refering the payday lending market to the Competition Commission after it found evidence of deep-rooted problems in how lenders compete with each other.


The action was announced in the final report on the OFT's compliance review of the £2 billion payday lending sector. The review found evidence of problems throughout the lifecycle of payday loans, from advertising to debt collection, and across the sector, including by leading lenders that are members of established trade associations.

Particular areas of non-compliance included:

  • lenders failing to conduct adequate assessments of affordability before lending or before rolling over loans
  • failing to explain adequately how payments will be collected
  • using aggressive debt collection practices
  • not treating borrowers in financial difficulty with forbearance.

The OFT says that payday lending is a top enforcement priority. Customers often have limited alternative sources of credit and are frequently in a vulnerable financial position. Combined with this, the high rates of interest charged by many payday lenders can make the consequences of irresponsible lending particularly acute. 

The OFT has also uncovered evidence suggesting that this market is not working well in other respects and that irresponsible lending in the sector may have its roots in the way competition works. 

Lenders were found to compete by emphasising the speed and easy access to loans rather than the price and also to be relying too heavily on rolling over or refinancing loans. The OFT believes that both these factors distort lenders' incentives to carry out proper affordability assessments as to do so would risk losing business to competitors. Too many people are granted loans they cannot afford to repay and it would appear that payday lenders' revenues are heavily reliant on those customers who fail to repay their original loan in full on time.

Despite payday loans being described as one-off short term loans, costing an average of £25 per £100 for 30 days, up to half of payday lenders' revenue comes from loans that last longer and cost more because they are rolled over or refinanced. The OFT also found that payday lenders are not competing with each other for this large source of revenue because by this time they have a captive market. 

Affordability (1)

Clive Maxwell, OFT Chief Executive, said:

'We have found fundamental problems with the way the payday market works and widespread breaches of the law and regulations, causing misery and hardship for many borrowers. Payday lenders are earning up to half their revenue not from one-off loans, but from rolled over or re-financed deals where unexpected costs can rapidly mount up.

'Irresponsible lending is not confined to a few rogue payday lenders - it is a problem across the sector. If we do not see rapid, significant improvements by the 50 lenders we inspected they risk their licences being removed. Payday lending is a top enforcement priority for the OFT.'

On 19 March 2013, the OFT withdrew the consumer credit licence of MCO Capital Limited, a payday loan provider.


Previous enforcement by the OFT

This is far from the first run-in that the industry has had with the authorities. Back in 2011 the logbook loan companies Nine Regions Limited ('NRL') and Log Book Loans Limited (together 'Log Book Loans') were deemed by the OFT to be unfit to hold consumer credit licences. A decision that was upheld on appeal.


Alternatives to Logbook and Payday loans

Many of the companies offering payday and logbook loans actively market to those who can't get credit through conventional means. That means that viable alternatives are thin on the ground. Credit Unions are one option. These arenot-for-profit, community-based organisations that provide loans to members, much in the same way that building societies used to serve their local communities. They're much cheaper than payday loans and give longer period to repay. APRs are generally between 20% and 30%  

Other ways to avoid a payday loan include asking your employer for an advance, selling stuff you don't need and requesting an authorised overdraft from your bank or building society (though this should also be treated with caution as it can be expensive).


Ask Honest John

Value my car

Amount to borrow
Sorry. The minimum loan amount is £1000
To pay back over

My credit score

Best available rate 9.20%

Total repayment £8,930.17

Total cost of credit £1,430.17


48 monthly payments

Apply now

Representative example

Borrowing £7,500 over 4 years with a representative APR of 25.4%, an annual interest rate of 25.4% (Fixed) and a deposit of £0.00, the amount payable would be £239.77 per month, with a total cost of credit of £4,008.96 and a total amount payable of £11,508.96.

CarFinance 247 Limited is acting as an independent credit broker

Universal Square, Devonshire Street North, Manchester, M12 6JH