Should I get a Volkswagen Caddy Maxi Life or a Fiat Doblo?

Which would be a better long term car, the Volkswagen Caddy Maxi Life or the Fiat Dolbo? I would be buying secondhand and keeping the car for 10 years minimum.

Asked on 13 November 2017 by P Stack

Answered by Dan Powell
The Volkswagen Caddy Maxi Life is better than the Fiat Doblo, so long as you choose a manual gearbox. The DSG boxes have a catalogue of reported problems and I'd always choose manual over an auto when buying used. It would also be wise to make checks about the DPF:

For more Volkswagen Caddy advice, see our buying guide:
Similar questions
I'm looking for an estate car/van-like car that would give me a big boot space. I need 6.25 feet in length and about 4 feet wide, to drive to Italy and back, but at a low cost - no glamour needed.
We need an automatic car as my wife is disabled and can only drive automatic. We also need a big enough boot to fit a mobility scooter, although we slide it in instead of lifting it over the boot sill....
We've had a Volkswagen Transporter (nine seater) but looking for more seats now, 10-12 but no bigger. Is the only option the Ford Minibus in the UK? We don't like the look and are rather accustomed to...
Related models
Sensibly priced seven-seater with enough space for seven and their luggage, huge loadspace with seats removed.
Huge space. Massively practical. Great diesel engines. Decent ride quality and hardwearing interior.

Ask Honest John

Value my car