Are diesel cars still a sound investment if they are being banned from places in the future?

With local authorities increasingly announcing plans to ban diesel engines from town centres from or before 2025 (however impractical this may sound), how can diesel now be a sound investment when buying a new car? If so, why are some car manufacturers (e.g. Volvo) still only offering diesel engines in their cars?

Asked on 29 December 2016 by

Answered by Honest John
Unless you will be driving at least 15,000 miles a year, diesel cars are no longer a "sound investment" when there is a viable petrol alternative. The emissions kit alone on a diesel engine (EGR, DPF, SCR) is not long-term reliable and will almost inevitably become troublesome and expensive to fix by 80,000 miles, and, if you drive only short distances, you can expect regular trouble with the DPF. The problem is, for many bigger cars such as SUVs, there aren't always viable alternatives, though for them petrol hybrid drivetrains are being developed and work. For example, even without plugging it in, a Volvo XC90 T8 PHEV is 25% more economical than an XC90 D5.
Similar questions
I'd like to buy a diesel BMW X3 2.0 but most of my journeys are short. What would be the negative effects on the car from my driving pattern? Are there any small changes to my driving, like doing a 50-mile...
There seems to be great deals on diesel cars at the moment, I thought an EU6 would be a good buy. With all the negative press surrounding diesel cars, is it worth buying a new diesel car? It will be used...
I'm undecided whether to buy a petrol Jaguar F-Pace 2.5 T R-Sport or a 2.0 diesel AWD180 auto (which we have tried and is adequate). The 2.5 petrol is £3130 list more than the 2.0d. The petrol has urban...
Related models
Incredibly refined and quiet on the move. High quality cabin with room for seven. Well equipped as standard. D5 is smooth yet punchy with good economy. T8 has tax advantages.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car