New Mazda CX-3 - AWD or 2WD with winter tyres?

Having finally settled on a new CX-3 I need to decide whether better to go for the 2WD and buy a set of winter wheels and tyres or just go for the AWD version (but no winter tyres) - I can do one or the other but not both as I would only need the spec of the SE-L as opposed to the AWD which for me is over-equipped.

Asked on 2 August 2015 by davidfulton

Answered by Honest John
Generally, full cold weather tyres will get you out of snow more effectively than four wheel drive. Even all season Michelin Cross Climate or Nokian Weatherproof will generally work better than four wheel drive. But four wheel drive with the cold weather or all season tyres is obviously best of the lot.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
We live in a rural location and occasionally have to contend with snow. Would you recommend the xDrive version of the BMW 320d Touring, or are winter tyres good enough with the standard 320d?
In your review of the Renault Captur, you mentioned there is 'No form of 'Grip Control' initially'. Are you hinting that this might be introduced at some later stage?
My husband is looking to replace our current S-Max with a car that will cope with snow and ice. He is looking at the Land Rover Discovery. We don't necessarily need 7 seats any more. Is there anything...
Related models
Enjoyable and good to drive. Good quality interior finish. 2.0-litre petrol is smooth and economical.

 

Value my car