New Freelander or used Discovery?

Not a terrible position to be in but I have the option of a new Freelander 2 XS as a company car (£270-80 per month tax at 40%) or a 5-6yr old Discovery 3 for 15-18k which would be paid for by the company allowance of £500 per month (£300 after tax).

When you weigh up insurance and possible issues with the Disco there's not a great deal in it I don't think. Possibly down to preference but your opinion would be much appreciated as I'm struggling to make a decision, I have had a 07 plate Freelander and loved it but feel I should sample a big boy's toy!?

Asked on 3 May 2013 by Andy

Answered by Honest John
No point in getting the Disco unless you regularly have the need to carry 7 people. You can only expect about 25mpg from the 2.7V6 diesel.
Similar questions
My Audi A6 has now reached the time to be replaced, 200000 good miles. The replaced falls between Honda CR-V or Suzuki Grand Vitara, as my future mileage will be 8000 miles per year the choice would be...
We have an old Suzuki Vitara for local and off-road use (which it does lots of) and we've been really pleased with it. We need another car for some commuting and longer runs but we live at the end of...
Essentials are : 4WD,40+mpg, Elec sun roof option, five doors, Elec full driver seat alteration. Petrol or diesel (annual mileage approx 24000), elevated driving position an advantage. Due to high...
Related models
Immensely competent in all environments from serious off roading and towing to motorways and country lanes. Handsome looks. Roomy, classy full seven-seater
Bigger than original Freelander. 2.2-litre belt cam diesel. Incredibly good off-road. Robust interior. More fuel efficient 2WD model from 2011 with no rear diff to fail.
 

Value my car