Better, or bargerine?

I'm ready to replace my current car (a great old workhorse - Peugeot 405 Executive TD) and I'm tempted by the relatively low prices of luxury cars due to the massive depreciation we're all seeing in this sector. I'm 50 years old now so insurance rates are also on my side, so the time could have come whereby I could consider driving something that a few years ago would seem way out of reach. A saloon would be OK but large enough for the fishing tackle etc. that I cart about in my 405. Clear HPI, full service history etc. would all be givens. My Budget is around £12,000 and the sort of cars I've been considering are BMW 5 series, Audi 6, VW Passat, Volvo S60 etc. I've even seen S class Mercedes (320s) from 02/03 in my price range. My gut feel is to go for Diesel for economy and grunt, but the cost difference now of petrol might suggest that it could offset the extra MPG that a Diesel offers. I'd like something that has a way to go before it breaks the 100,000-mile psychological threshold, for potential resale purposes as much as anything. Taking into account reliability (your articles have put me off an E class Merc), running costs etc. am I being realistic in getting a bargain for my budget, and if so are there any stand-out winners.

Asked on 20 March 2010 by S.P., Newmarket

Answered by Honest John
The fact is that repair bills for a £60,000 car bought for £12,000 reflect the £60,000 rather than the £12,000. Are you up for some very serious potential bills? Or are you generally lucky? You can reduce the odds quite a bit by opting for a Lexus. Japanese 'quality' far exceeds anything out of Germany.

Honest John recommends carwow – find and buy your perfect car, in just a few clicks

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I am a graduate with a budget of £2000 looking to buy a cheap, luxury car for mainly motorway miles - about 6000 a year. I don't mind paying a premium for insurance, fuel and maintenance so long as the...
I am looking to buy a 2006 S-Class W221 which has done 98K miles and comes with 1 year dealer warranty. it has been converted to LPG. Can I ask how expensive is it to maintain and service the car. Are...
I am well into retirement and only travel about 5k miles a year. We already have a small car [Toyota IQ] and would like the comfort of a bigger car for the few longer journeys, but only have a limited...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car