Do I really need a 4x4 to drive in snow and ice?

Do I really need 4x4 for snow/ice? Or are the many twp-wheel drive SUVs on sale right now better in winter weather than a standard hatchback? I'm looking for something to deal with rural Scottish weather with a petrol engine and manual gearbox, up to about £10,000.

Asked on 18 November 2019 by Mark Jessop

Answered by Andrew Brady
You'd be surprised at the difference a good set of winter tyres makes. They are designed to perform when the temperature drops below 7 degrees, so even in cold but dry temperatures, they'll perform better than summer tyres. Depending on how much space you need, I'd be looking for something like a Suzuki Vitara or Honda CR-V and fitting a set of winter tyres. Unless you plan on driving through muddy fields, these should be sufficient for your needs.
Similar questions
What's the best for coping with winter conditions - all year tyres, winter tyres or 4-wheel drive? In what order do you rate these?
I drive a 2017 RAV4 Hybrid on the edge of the Peak District. Is it worth investing in winter tyres?
I live in the Peak District and drive a Ford Fiesta but because of winter weather conditions, I decided to swap it for a Skoda Yeti. However, I've been told that getting winter tyres would be the best...
Related models
Luxurious and more efficient than before. Was the softest riding and most stress-free SUV under £30,000. 1.6-litre i-DTEC is impressively refined and quiet.
Very good to drive and comfortable. Lots of interior space. Five star Euro NCAP rating. Relatively economical. Excellent 1.0 BoosterJet engines.

Ask Honest John

Value my car