What car should I buy that's fun but economical?

I am 69 and generally reasonably fit and still working. Three months ago I decided that I really needed a car with a higher driving position. I fancied a MINI Countryman, but the only one near to me and not white was a Cooper S version. As I still enjoy driving and a bit of performance I bought it privately. I love it but I am horrified at the fuel consumption, my journey to work is outside of the rush hour 6.5 miles on A roads and dual carriageways. If I just let the torque do the work and change up at 3000 revs I am averaging 33 mpg. If I actually enjoy a bit of a blast every day I get just over 20 mpg.

I am retiring next February and will change it next spring with a budget of £7000. I need to get two large dogs in the back What would you suggest?

Asked on 7 November 2018 by Steve Hubbard

Answered by Andrew Brady
It doesn't sound like you will be covering many miles, so we'd advise avoiding a diesel. We'd be inclined to keep the Countryman, if you like it. The cars you've mentioned will feel like a bit of a step-down and, if you're not covering many miles, the fuel savings will be wiped out by the cost of changing cars. If you do want to change, I reckon a Skoda Yeti would suit your requirements well. You'd probably enjoy the 1.8 TSI petrol but it's thirsty (our readers report around 31mpg on average: www.honestjohn.co.uk/realmpg/skoda/yeti-2009). Look for a 1.4 TSI for the best combination of performance and economy.
Similar questions
What’s the most economical diesel, estate?
I commute at least 80 miles a day but only drive an automatic. My budget is £6500. What is the most economical car in my budget?
We are looking to buy a used family SUV that is economical and reliable. We’d want to avoid the small SUVs (Qashqai) and need a but more space. Can you recommend something below £12,000?.
Related models
Unique styling. Solid build. Excellent petrol engines including frugal yet peppy 1.2 TSI. Good space in the back. Frugal 1.6 TDI Greenline can return 60mpg+.

 

Value my car