Mechanical Aptitude test - Clanger
Apologies if it's been done before but I can't find it. Test yourself on these 50 questions and report your score back. I got a below average 84.

www.forddoctorsdts.com/quizzes/MechanicalAptitude....p


Hawkeye
-----------------------------
Stranger in a strange land
Mechanical Aptitude test - teabelly
I got 60, which for a mechanical numpty is rather good :-)
teabelly
Mechanical Aptitude test - Garethj
I did this last week and got 90%

I question their correct answer about what causes air to get sucked into the combustion chamber - I said it was the piston moving down and they say it's atmospheric pressure, but surely either (or in fact both) are correct?
Mechanical Aptitude test - DP
I said it was the piston moving down and they say it's atmospheric
pressure


Me too!

Cheers
DP
--
04 Grand Scenic 1.9 dCi Dynamique
00 Mondeo 1.8TD LX
Mechanical Aptitude test - Mapmaker
Me too.

I'm also not certain that 'friction' is a mechanical motion principle; decceleration, however, I suggest is.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Altea Ego
I'm also not certain that 'friction' is a mechanical motion principle; decceleration however I suggest
is.


Mappy are you therefore saying there are only 4 mechanical motion principals?

none, acceleration, steady speed, decceleration?
------------------------------
< Ex RF, Ex TVM >
Mechanical Aptitude test - daveyjp
"I question their correct answer about what causes air to get sucked into the combustion chamber "

They shoudn't use the word 'suck' as this suggests air is somehow pulled into the chamber. It isn't it's pushed in in the same was as air enters your lungs. When you breath you move your chest cavity which increase the volume of the lungs and air enters due to the pressure difference.

Its the same principle which appleis to using a drinking straw. Whilst you have been taught to suck, it's actually air pressure forcing liquid up the straw.
Mechanical Aptitude test - L'escargot
...... a drinking straw. Whilst you have been
taught to suck it's actually air pressure forcing liquid up the straw.


It's actually the pressure difference between one end and the other that causes the liquid to flow up/along the straw. And it's the sucking at one end that results in the pressure difference.

I really must stop allowing myself to be drawn into this type of discussion! ;-)
--
L\'escargot.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Altea Ego
School Theory

"Nature abhors a vaccuum"

So you create a vacuum, and nature (atmospheric pressure) fills it. The root cause however is the piston going down, causing the vacuum that atmospheric pressure fills.

Its a badly worded question.




------------------------------
< Ex RF, Ex TVM >
Mechanical Aptitude test - Tomo
I could not fathom that one and said the air was sucked in by the piston moving down, having tossed between that and atmospheric pressure. Hence 94%.
Mechanical Aptitude test - DP
Oh yes, and I failed with 70%

With next to no knowledge of electronics or physics though I was never going to do well.

Cheers
DP

--
04 Grand Scenic 1.9 dCi Dynamique
00 Mondeo 1.8TD LX

Edited by DP on 24/10/2007 at 11:01

Mechanical Aptitude test - normd2
80% - passed but only just :)
Mechanical Aptitude test - boxsterboy
Oh yes and I failed with 70%
With next to no knowledge of electronics or physics though I was never going to
do well.


Great minds think alike! (and for the same reasons!)
Mechanical Aptitude test - J Bonington Jagworth
"electronics or physics"

Difficult to see what electronics have to do with mechanical aptitude!

I also wondered about the 'mechanical motion principle', since that seemed to be steering the answer away from 'friction'. Still, I wouldn't be complaining if I'd got it right...

Mechanical Aptitude test - J Bonington Jagworth
Hmm.. 2 wrong. Will discuss later!
Mechanical Aptitude test - SteVee
92percent - but I missed the bit where they told me which answers were wrong.
I may have been misled by the the air entering the cylinder question too
Mechanical Aptitude test - L'escargot
I got the website, but the test didn't show. There was a little box with a red cross in it, but it didn't respond to either a left or a right click. What am I doing wrong?
--
L\'escargot.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Altea Ego
what browser you using? its needs be able to load the adobe flash plug in.
------------------------------
< Ex RF, Ex TVM >
Mechanical Aptitude test - Altea Ego
46/50 92%

Got 4 wrong

7, 8, 19, 48.

Tho I am sure I was right on 48. Its the vacuum that causes air to enter the piston, is this suction or atmospheric pressure. Conflict of terms perhaps.
------------------------------
< Ex RF, Ex TVM >
Mechanical Aptitude test - Mapmaker
>>Its the vacuum that causes air to enter the piston

That it's certainly not. It's an area of lower-than-atmospheric pressure.

Which is itself caused by the piston moving down, which causes atmospheric pressure to push air into the cylinder.

Bad question.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Altea Ego
Ok so its not a true vacuum. Its a vacuum effect tho.

The air entering the piston is a consequence of the vacuum effect (or area of lower pressure)
So whats the cause? the cause is the piston going down.

Agree bad question.


------------------------------
< Ex RF, Ex TVM >
Mechanical Aptitude test - mike hannon
Odd for a Ford site - didn't notice anything on how you re-programme an injector or where you buy the purest diesel for your TDCI ;-)
Mechanical Aptitude test - DP
^^^^^^PMSL ^^^^^

I thought something similar but then thought it was a bit of a cheap shot ;-)

Cheers
DP
--
04 Grand Scenic 1.9 dCi Dynamique
00 Mondeo 1.8TD LX
Mechanical Aptitude test - George Porge
84% :o)
Mechanical Aptitude test - tyro
Grrrr. I was beaten for the "mechanical numpty" award by teabelly. 68%.

Mind you, 6 or 7 of my wild guesses turned out to be correct!
Mechanical Aptitude test - movilogo
Made 82% (ie 41/50)

Faltered on electrical and little bit on hydraulics! On two pulley questions guesstimate appeared to be correct!

Mechanical Aptitude test - component part
86%, although at least a couple of the questions I answered in haste and realised I had hit the incorrect answer as I submitted it-so my adjusted score is over 90% :-). Couldn't get my head around that worm screw question-don't get me wrong I understand it but couldn't get my brain to see the thread turn direction :-(
Mechanical Aptitude test - J Bonington Jagworth
"is this suction or atmospheric pressure"

Fair question, and an unfair distinction in a quiz, IMHO. Suction is the observable effect of allowing atmospheric pressure to do its work when there is an imbalance. Centrifugal force doesn't officially exist either, but everyone knows what it is, and even scientists use centrifuges (and suction pumps)...
Mechanical Aptitude test - Screwloose

If the piston remains static; then the air stays where it is.

Therefore the only answer is the action of moving the piston causes the air to enter.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Garethj
If the piston remains static; then the air stays where it is.
Therefore the only answer is the action of moving the piston causes the air to enter.


This is like that "chicken and egg" conversation the rats have at the end of the Chicken Run film ;-)
Mechanical Aptitude test - paulb {P}
90%. Couldn't get the worm drive one right in my head, for no good reason.

Memo to self: connecting batteries in SERIES increases voltage. Duh.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Number_Cruncher
92%

I felt that the questions were rather badly worded. I would hope that they wouldn't appear like that on a real examination question.

It might be more accurate to say that nature abhors pressure! (being that most of the universe is remarkably close to vacuum conditions)

Number_Cruncher
Mechanical Aptitude test - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}
82%. No idea which I got wrong.
The long belt and series of pulleys gave me a headache.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Cliff Pope
90%.
I got the suck/air pressure one right, it having been drummed into us years ago at school that there was no such thing as suck, like centrifugal force.
But I thought a lot of the questions were badly worded. I pondered over the angled shot of the bevel gears - did it mean direction as we view it, or is there a convention regarding gears on the end of shafts?

Major fault we would have been shot for at school - Kg etc is a MASS not a FORCE. The unit of force would be a Kilogram-weight.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Group B
I plumped for atmospheric pressure; ISTR reading a definition of 'naturally aspirated' in an engineering dictionary which said "air enters due to atmospheric pressure".
I can't find a more highbrow source but good old Wikipedia says the above, but then you click a link and it says vacuum + air pressure + venturi effect of valves. So a bit ambiguous.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspirated

But I fluffed the quiz on some of the gearing and electrical questions and got 86%, with much twirling of fingers to imagine gears/ fans turning!

;o)
Mechanical Aptitude test - Sim-O
What does everyone mean 'There's no such thing as suck or centrifugal'?
How is all the air removed from a vacuum vessel (what ever it's called) and how do the motorbikes stay on the wall in the Wall of Death if there's no such thing as centrifugal force?
----------------------------------------------
Aim low, expect nothing & dont be disappointed

Edited by Sim-O on 24/10/2007 at 14:19

Mechanical Aptitude test - hxj
how do the motorbikes stay on the wall in the Wall of Death if there's
no such thing as centrifugal force?


By angling the bike slightly up the wall and driving fast enough to ensure that the 'down' force provided by gravity is matched by the 'up' force from the bike.

It's no different from steering slightly into a crosswind to avoid being blown off the road.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Mapmaker
There is no such thing as centrifugal force.

Imagine a conker. Forget about gravity for a moment, so float it in mid air. Give it a gentle push, and it will want to disappear off in a straight line.

Now dangle the conker on a piece of string. Again, give it a gentle horizontal push, and it will try to disappear off horizontally. Things move in straight lines unless subject to additional forces. BUT, it's attached to a piece of string. So it has to go in a circle. The string is constraining its movement into a circle; therefore the string is exerting a force on the conker. We call it a centripetal force.

Now, whizz the conker round in a circle and cut the string. It will fly off at a tangent to the circle. You have removed the centripetal force that is keeping it on its circular track, so it goes off in a straight line. There is no "centrifugal" force acting on the conker; there is in fact no force at all acting on the conker - that's why it goes in a straight line. So there certainly can't be a centrifugal force.

But you say, I can feel centrifugal force. If I throw a hammer in athletics, I can feel it trying to move away from me. It can dislocate my shoulder! The answer is no. You are in fact applying a centripetal force to the hammer. It is not applying a centrifugal force to you.

Centrifugal force is perhaps sloppy shorthand for "absence of centripetal force".


Mechanical Aptitude test - Altea Ego
Centrifugal Force

an outward force on a body rotating about an axis, assumed equal and opposite to the centripetal force and postulated to account for the phenomena seen by an observer in the rotating body.
------------------------------
< Ex RF, Ex TVM >
Mechanical Aptitude test - Sim-O
Ok. That's centrifugal force sorted. I think.
What about 'there's no such thing as suck'?
----------------------------------------------
Aim low, expect nothing & dont be disappointed
Mechanical Aptitude test - bignick2
What about 'there's no such thing as suck'?
----------------------------------------------



An example of what I think is called a "privative" i.e. a noun which is the absence of something. The classic example is DARK which is not a thing in itself merely the absence of light.

cf the works of Terry Pratchett
Mechanical Aptitude test - daveyjp
'Suck' is a verb.

To suck

End of English class.
Mechanical Aptitude test - J Bonington Jagworth
"much twirling of fingers to imagine gears/ fans turning!"

Same here. The fans were particularly tricky, I thought. I took 'turning in the same direction' to mean WRT the fan, but of course they meant WRT the illustration...

(one's blowing, and the other's turning as if to suck*)

*assuming such a thing is possible :-)
Mechanical Aptitude test - Chris M
86%

Good fun for a lunchtime.
Mechanical Aptitude test - bignick2
scraped through with 80

hangs head in shame and wanders back to work as a motor trade professional
Mechanical Aptitude test - helicopter
Ooer .....Horrible memories of physics lessons at school 45 or so years ago.

I did the test very quickly , took a few wild guesses and failed . I got clickety click in bingo parlance so not quite as bad as some.

Should have paid more attention in class - Must try harder.........
Mechanical Aptitude test - Lud
Only 88%, and frankly I am miffed.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Cliff Pope
That's very well put, mapmaker, if I may say so.

I think I could have got 100 %, he says modestly, if I had given some of the questions a bit more thought. I started quite seriously, but when I saw I was still only half way through I got deliberately careless and started ticking intuitively.
Good fun though.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Round The Bend
68 and proud! Guessed a few which probably upped my score.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Aretas
88% but haven't a clue how you which are right and which are wrong. It told me I was wrong on only one of the questions.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Lud
I never noticed it telling me I was wrong. But I was a bit hasty a couple of times.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Group B
It told me I was wrong on only one of the questions.



I got half way through, answered a question and a box popped up saying "correct!". I thought: was that a special bonus question or have I got them all wrong so far!?
A glitch in the software..

Edited by Rich 9-3 on 24/10/2007 at 18:06

Mechanical Aptitude test - gordonbennet
Scraped pathetically by with 82 memories of napthalene experiments come trickling back,

Enjoyed the test though.

Would like to know how any of our younger say under 30 did on test
Mechanical Aptitude test - pendulum
Would like to know how any of our younger say under 30 did on test


I'm 22... scraped a pass - 82% :o)

As soon as I saw "mechanical aptitude" I thoguht ut-oh... but most of the questions were reasonable. I was let down by the weight questions (and star/ring gears - what are they?) but got all the electrical ones right to make up for it.

Oh and by the way, if anyone wants to know which answers they got right or wrong at the end, press the icon that looks like a lopsided pause button labelled "Show/hide TOC" when you scroll over it.

Edited by pendulum on 08/11/2007 at 10:55

Mechanical Aptitude test - Mapmaker
>>That's very well put, mapmaker, if I may say so.

Thank you. The "centrifugal is absence of centripetal" phrase is copyright to RKD who taught me Physics. Thank you Sir.


>>"No such thing as suck"

I don't think I agree. It's all about pressure imbalance. You can either increase the pressure within a piston, or reduce it. The end result is a movement of fluid in order to rectify the imbalance. Suck describes very clearly that the pressure is reduced.

If your pump sucks, it is limited to - what - 12m of water; if it pushes you are limited only by the power of your pump.
Mechanical Aptitude test - David Horn
*Smug mode on*

94%

*Smug mode off*
Mechanical Aptitude test - Manatee
Modesty prevents me revealing my score - suffice to say I thoroughly approve of the test ;-)

i don't think think the piston question was ambiguous at all - it was essentially , "does the movement of the piston suck the air in or is it pushed in by atmospheric pressure" - it didn't say "is it caused by the movement of the piston".

To illustrate that it is atmospheric pressure, consider the effects of different pressure levels - the amount of air pushed in is greater at higher pressures, even thought the piston movement is the same. Reducto ad absurdum, if no atmospheric pressure, no air movement, regardless of piston antics.

Alternatively, consider the maximum height you can raise a column of liquid to - with a vacuum above it, the height is proportional to the atmospheric pressure - it's that wot does it!

Edited by Manatee on 24/10/2007 at 22:18

Mechanical Aptitude test - J Bonington Jagworth
"does the movement of the piston suck the air in or is it pushed in by atmospheric pressure"

If you accept the notion of 'sucking', which is not only popularly understood, but used as part of the question, then both are true. If they wanted to be scientifically correct, they shouldn't have used the term in the first place!

IIRC, the shorthand description of the Otto cycle is 'suck, squeeze, bang, blow'...
Mechanical Aptitude test - mfarrow
92%

That atmosphere piston question, brakes, badly-worded epicyclic geartrain question, and why can't you use a camshaft to translate reciprocating motion (in theory!)?

--------------
Mike Farrow

Edited by mfarrow {P} on 24/10/2007 at 20:00

Mechanical Aptitude test - Sprice
Yawn. As always, the egomaniacs on this site just have to argue about whether some phenomena exists or not.
Mechanical Aptitude test - Westpig
60%.......... and surprised i did so well
Mechanical Aptitude test - bell boy
ive tried twice today to complete this test but got bored.......sorry.... :--(
Mechanical Aptitude test - Happy Blue!
84%. Never did pulleys in physics at school (remarkably for one of the top five in the country at the time - The Manchester Grammar School). Didn't like the worm drive question and one or two others caught me unawares. Luckily I remembered all the electrical ones and the children's gear toy came in very handy!
Mechanical Aptitude test - Mapmaker
>>Yawn. As always, the egomaniacs on this site just have to argue about whether some phenomena exists or not.


Well don't bother reading it!
Mechanical Aptitude test - bignick2
and why can't you use a
camshaft to translate reciprocating motion (in theory!)?


Surely a camshaft does exactly the opposite in turning rotary motion of the shaft into reciprocal motion of the valves. It wont work in the reverse direction as there is no fixed link to the valve. The crankshaft however does work in reverse when starting the engine turning rotary motion imparted by the starter into reciprocal motion of the pistons.
Mechanical Aptitude test - horatio
Thank you for the quiz, I enjoyed that.

90% for me

got these wrong

7. (Sun, planetary gears & outer ring) I chose the sun gear to stop, I couldn't get my head around any other outcome - but I can accept I was wrong there - but it is very difficult to envisage. And I need a working model to see it in action.

16. 100kg weight tied to pulley, rope on pulley tied to vertical wall and your hand at other end. I said 100kg. Should have realised it was like lifting with 2 people.

26. 3 bulbs in cicuit, what happens when you "short circuit" one bulb, I decided to say it would still light up (3 bulbs light) because I was taught that no matter what some current will always travel along a path of more resistance (most current will pass along the path of least resistance but some will go along the other path, thus the bulb will glow but dimmer than usual) Am I right?

Qu 38. I did not get this wrong, but I was unhappy with the wording of the question. Two identical fans facing each other one fan turned on, what will other fan do? Well obviously the wind will turn the fan, and it if you look at the fans facing the front of each fan in turn the direction of fan #2 will be opposite rotation from fan #1, but if you observe the fans from the sideways on as in the picture, both fans will have the blades at the top turning towards you, and the blades at the bottom turning away from you, so it could be said they are turning in the same direction, but equally #1 is turning clockwise #2 anti clockwise, it all depends on your viewpoint and how you define "direction of rotation." But like I say I got this one correct by guessing what they interpreted as "the same direction".

39. (I got this one correct too but I have seen some discussion above people didn't like the answer) so here goes.... What mechanical motion principle do car brakes employ?
Key word there being "employ" they employ friction, deceleration is a result. Friction is always present as a mechanical force acting against motion - except in a true vacuum using a maglev train or zero gravity.

45. All 3 balloons contain the same amount of gas. The outside atmospheric pressure is the greatest on which ballon? Now this one I got wrong, because surely atmospheric pressure is the same in any given room. The question did not say if all 3 balloons were in the same room at the same time - which would indicate to me (given that atmospheric pressure is constant) that the balloons are made of different materials (contain same amount of gas). I assumed like the picture given that the 3 balloons were side by side in the same room.

If the balloon material is the same for all 3 and they are in 3 seperate rooms, then yes the only variable can be the room pressure, and the smallest ballon would logically be in the room with the highest pressure. But the question was not clear as to what the conditions were. Actually it is the same ballon put into 3 different pressure chambers - why didn't they just say that?

48. Air pushed in or sucked in? That is the question (chicken or the egg?). I got this wrong and said it was sucked in. However I like others do dispute I am wrong. The cause for the air to enter is twofold, the piston moves and air enters to take up the space. If the piston did not move the air would not enter. If there was no air (vacuum) no air would enter. Both answers are wrong and both answers are correct it is infact a combination of the two. Otherwise if they are right there is no such thing as "sucking" so why is sucking defined in dictionaries?

suck:
?verb (used with object)
1. to draw into the mouth by producing a partial vacuum by action of the lips and tongue:
Mechanical Aptitude test - DP
I got the same questions wrong as horatio (plus a few more besides) but with exactly the same answers, thought processes and logic.

I'm feeling a bit better now.

Cheers
DP
--
04 Grand Scenic 1.9 dCi Dynamique
00 Mondeo 1.8TD LX
Mechanical Aptitude test - pmh
94%

Similar mistakes or reasoning to Horatio!

7. (Sun, planetary gears & outer ring) I reckon I would make the same mistake again on rereading the question!

38. I did get this wrong, but I was unhappy with the wording of the question. Two identical fans facing each other one fan turned on, what will other fan do?

All depends on whether you regard' the same direction' as when you view from the side or whether the natural powered turning direction !

45. All 3 balloons contain the same amount of gas. The outside atmospheric pressure is the greatest on which balloon?

I opted for the room that they are all in being at normal atm pressure.

Like so many trivia questions the wording is an indication of the intellect of the setter of the questions. I wont even get into the force/weight/mass issues.

But still alight hearted way to waste your life away.


--

pmh (was peter)


Mechanical Aptitude test - lotusexige
92% also and missed the bit at the end where they tell you hwre you went wrong. I did notice the one which poped up correct.

Edited by lotusexige on 25/10/2007 at 17:05

Mechanical Aptitude test - ijws15
Another 92% - a bit dissapointing for an MIMechE !

Wording on some questions very poor - especially the fan!
Mechanical Aptitude test - tyro
I persuaded my wife to do the test. 84%.

Only 16% more than me. Most disappointing. I thought she'd get at least 90%.

Anyone else have a mechanically minded wife?
Mechanical Aptitude test - J Bonington Jagworth
"Anyone else have a mechanically minded wife?"

Good question - I haven't tested her lately...
Mechanical Aptitude test - Snakey
Ooo 68%! Better than I expected. And I skipped over a couple because I got bored of looking at pulleys!
Mechanical Aptitude test - GroovyMucker
84%.

I question the validity of any test in which I can score that highly.

Mechanical Aptitude test - J Bonington Jagworth
"of any test in which I can score that highly"

..or belong to any club that would have you as a member? :-)
(c) G.Marx
Mechanical Aptitude test - wildcolonial
One wrong due to not knowing the difference between "rotate" and "turn" on the planetary gear question #8, although I did visualize it correctly.
I was lucky with the multiple pulley one, which to me was much harder than most of the rest.
I think it helps not to presume too sharp an intelligence on the questioning end, as in the sucking piston question which is the kind of "arcane" info small minds delight in one-upping others with to no particular end.
Mechanical Aptitude test - corblimeyguvnar
66%
which I am quite flabbergasted at, some of those diagrams I havent seen since school, which was a long time ago, would have been chuffed at anything above 10.

Still failed though :-(
--
Drink Lager, Talk Piffle,
Mechanical Aptitude test - buzbee
92% first time, (some days ago) and exited without reviewing my answers. Just been back to find out my mistakes and got just the worm gear one wrong. I found tricky to know which way the thread was moving.