Ford Fiesta ST (2004 – 2008) Review

Ford Fiesta ST (2004 – 2008) At A Glance

Performance Fiesta. Cheap, sharp and huge fun to drive.

Some drivers might find it too edgy. Go faster stripes best avoided.

Satisfaction Index

Reviews for Ford Fiesta ST (2004 – 2008)'s top 3 rivals

Skoda Octavia

Practical and refined performance version of latest Octavia. Available with excellent TSI engine or more...

Volkswagen Golf

Golf GTI performs well in every area, making it the consummate all-round hot hatch.

Ford Fiesta

Performance car bargain, there are few better hot hatches to drive at any price than Ford’s Fiesta ST,...

Ask Honest John

Can you suggest a family car with classic car potential?

"I'm looking for a family car to replace my 2006 Audi A3 2.0 TFSI. I only drive 6000 miles per year, so depreciation and road tax are my biggest expenses. Can you recommend a used car, that doesn't exceed £20,000, that could hold its value or even appreciate. I'd also like it to be reasonable in terms of road tax and mpg."

Your budget isn't enough to stretch to the high-end cars like Ferrari, and a modern classic within your price range needs to be a sports car if it's going to hold it's value - which excludes your criteria of it being a family car, and being inexpensive to tax and returning decent mpg. Perhaps something like a Renault Avantime would fit the bill? It's definitely a future classic and more than capable of moving the family. Failing that, there's a strong following for Land Rover, so a Defender might work - but it will feel very agricultural compared to your current vehicle. If you need something more middle of the road, try the new Ford Fiesta ST (although you'll have to ride the depreciation curve) or try and jump on the hot hatch wagon, with the Golf GTI or 205 GTI looking like good bets for an all-rounder.

Answered by Keith Moody

I have £6000 for a fun, economic and reliable car - any suggestions?

"I have about £6000 to spend on a used car. I'll use it for a daily 25 mile commute in rush hour and, as my wife has a Volkswagen Up!, it will be our main car for longer journeys. I'd like a balance of fun, good fuel economy (at least 30mpg), comfort (for those dark, icy days) and reliability. I'm thinking a Ford Fiesta 1.6 petrol Or a Honda Civic Type S. Or an older MINI Cooper S/DS3 THP. Which do you think I should I go for or can you think of any alternatives?"

£6000 will probably get you a first generation Fiesta ST, which is a bit raw but fun. MINI generally aren't very reliable. The DS3 1.6 THP 150 is fun and comfortable but can have timing chain problems. The Civic 1.8 i-VTEC SE makes more sense than the 3-door Type S and does over 40mpg.

Answered by Honest John

Which hatchback should I buy?

"I have a fair budget for a used car, preferably a petrol hot hatch with reasonable MPG consumption and also suitable for everyday car use. I am thinking of something up to a 2.0-litre engine. I am looking currently at the SEAT Ibiza III FR, SEAT Leon Cupra, SEAT Ibiza VI FR, SEAT Leon, Audi S3, Audi A3, Audi quattro, Volkswagen Golf V GTI, and Volkswagen Polo V. Can you please advice me what is the best choice and also what are the most common issues with the above cars."

The current Ibiza Cupra 1.8 TSI or Polo GTI 1.8 TSI are good, but a Ford Fiesta ST goes and handles better. Avoid Audi A1, Ibiza and Polo with the 1.4 Twincharger engine and DSG transmission. Current A3 with EA888 engine okay; previous one had trouble with timing chain, piston rings and coking up of inlet valves. The current SEAT Leon FR 1.8 TSI with independent rear suspension is okay. I'd avoid the previous generation of hot Leon because they are ugly. Avoid Golf V and VI because they are the most troublesome cars recorded. Polo and Ibiza 1.2 with timing chains can have timing chain trouble. Check them all out at http://www.honestjohn.co.uk/carbycar/

Answered by Honest John

Ford Fiesta ST speed sensor problems

"The speed sensor on my Ford Fiesta ST needs replacing and I've been told its within the ABS Module. Would you recommend a new one and getting it coded or a refurb? "

Mixed message here. The speed sensor is in the final drive and the common fault is failure of the oil gasket allowing diff oil into the sensor. Costs £100 - £150 to replace. The common fault with the ABS module is the brake pressure sensor and that can be replaced by sending the module off to http://www.ecutesting.com for repair, which costs about £400 + removal, shipping and refitting.

Answered by Honest John

On the inside of an Ford Fiesta ST (2004 – 2008)

Though it goes well and the seats are very comfortable and supportive, the ST simply isn't for me. And I kind of wonder who it is for.

In theory it's ideal for the under 25s who traditionally buy fast Fiestas. But it's Group 13 insurance, which is going to cost under 25s an arm and a leg on top of the £13,595 list price.

I guess there'll be a race series that will shift some. Maybe the market is really 25 - 30 year olds. Perhaps thirtysomething former XR2 owners now running Jags will buy them as second cars out of nostalgia. The really keen will have them for track days. But I can't foresee Ford moving metal in the numbers they used to as XR2s.

Child seats that fit a Ford Fiesta ST (2004 – 2008)

Our unique Car Seat Chooser shows you which child car seats will fit this car and which seat positions that they will fit, so that you don't have to check every car seat manufacturer's website for compatibility.

Which car seat will suit you?

Driving Ford Fiesta ST (2004 – 2008)

It has a mildly breathed-on chain-cam Mondeo engine putting out 150PS, dropped and stiffened suspension, big 17" alloys with 205/40 section tyres and, for £150 extra, two wide police alert Carlos Fandango ‘go faster' stripes the length of the bonnet and roof.

It looks particularly good in white with blue stripes, the old Ford motor sports colours, but you can also have red, blue or black with white stripes, and stripes along the side for an extra £75. There's a single-slot CD player for that authentic ‘boom boom' noise. And the exhaust pipe has been specially tuned to sound like a 1960s rally car. So the spirit of the original boy racer XR2 has been re-incarnated in the current Fiesta body.

How does it all come together?

The engine revs very freely, the suspension is rock hard and the responses are instant, so if you want to work at your driving you can put up some pretty quick A to B times on your favourite roads. And I guess it's stiff enough to be a decent track-day car too. There was a bit of variation between the cars on test; one displaying an alarming tail waggle at times, hopefully a pre-production quirk of that particular car. And the ancient Ford fumble of a big gap between 2nd and 3rd gears seems to have returned. Close ratios they aren't.

What I can crystal ball is a lot of youngsters hankering after the ST, then being quoted £3k a year to insure it, so plumping for the 100PS Group 7 Fiesta Zetec 1.6S instead (which we didn't get to test).

To Telegraph readers, the new slightly sporty Fusion Zetec S with a 90PS version of PSA and Ford's ‘Duratorq' 1.6 16 valve common rail diesel makes more sense. Fusions never really took off in the UK, despite their slightly higher driving position and their huge rear loadspace with flat low-loading sill. A peculiar omission is no grab handle over the front passenger seat, which isn't going to help the elderly and infirm make entry and exit. But for a small, tall car the Zetec S version handles decently enough. A bit better than a Mitsubishi Colt or the class-leading Honda Jazz, though no better than its stablemate Mazda 2. And the EU IV 90PS diesel gives it a decent combination of performance and economy just short of the magic 120g/km CO2 so annual VED is £115 rather than £85.

Fortunately Ford saved the best for last. The Fiesta Zetec S with the same 90PS ‘Duratorq' diesel engine.

This isn't just extremely cheap to run at £85pa annual VED and an average 63mpg, it's also a lot of fun. The suspension is more compliant than the ST, there's a bit less rubber on the road, no ‘ESP' switch (and no need for one) and one of the sweetest revving diesels you can buy. It begs the question why they didn't go all out for the 110PS version as fitted to the Peugeot 205 GTI HDI 110. The answer could be that the 110 wouldn't have qualified for £85pa VED. Or that it would have been so good it would have stolen the thunder of the ST. Or that PSA simply wouldn't let Ford have it for the Fiesta.

Still, for me, despite just 90PS, the Fiesta Zetec S diesel was car of the day. It rode well. It handled astonishingly well and felt like it would continue to do so in the wet. It put a smile on my face. And I reckon I'd probably end up getting around 55mpg day to day against maybe 35mpg from the ST, so I wouldn't have to go and get robbed at a service station quite as often. It's even cheap to insure in Group 6E. So it's the fast Fiesta that gets the thumbs up here and I'll leave the ST to the enthusiasts who like that sort of thing.

Living With a Fiesta ST150 

For reasons I won't bore you with I wound up with an all-black RHD ST150 on extended test for 3 weeks. 

After our Thai Toyota Soluna Vios and a Mitsubishi Lancer estate, the Fiesta first felt so full-on tight, hard and darty I thought I was going to have a tough time not crashing it. Since I like a bit of compliance in the suspension, this was a real culture shock. And geared at 20mph per 1,000 rpm in top it's hardly a relaxing cruiser either. 

But thats not what it's about. What it is about is making the Fiesta as close to a track-day car as can be done. And when you think of it that way, it succeeds very well. 

It forces you to concentrate on driving it properly. And then it can be very satisfying. 

They must have changed the gear ratios from the original test cars, because now a short third gear gives hard acceleration, which is very useful pulling onto a motorway. There is actually bags of grip and adjustability. On straights the din from the engine discourages serious speed. But get to some corners and that Mercedes that was eating your back bumper suddenly becomes a Dinky Toy in your mirror. So the ST150 can be huge fun. And is even more accessible now that real world prices have been cut to around £11,000.

Good

Bad

What to watch out for

Recalls

Model History

• January 2008: Two special dealer-fit tuning packs from January 2008
• June 2008: Limited edition Fiesta ST500 announced