Should I trade my 2006 Jaguar S Type in for the newer model?

I bought a 2006 Jaguar S Type 2.7-litre diesel back in April while I was between jobs to see me through. Having now returned to work I am wondering whether I should replace the car for a newer model, say a 3.0-litre diesel Jaguar XF at £15,000 plus trade-in, but as the current car is fine and in good condition it seems a waste to trade it in. I have recently had it serviced and replaced the cam belt as it had reached 80,000. I know you say that there are DPF issues with older diesels but I will be doing 15-20,000 miles a year so a diesel is necessary. What would your advice be given that I am happy with the S Type and what should I do to ensure the longevity of the car?

Asked on 29 December 2016 by clivej

Answered by Honest John
If you're happy, keep it. Quite a few problems with XFs. Got into the top 10 most complained about cars: Your timing belt was wise. Problems with S-Type here:
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
My car is a Mercedes-Benz A220 CDI auto. It has most optional extras and I've owned it from new. It's done 15,000 miles and will soon need an MoT, major servicing and two new tyres. Whilst I have enjoyed...
I'm currently working overseas, but upon my return to the UK next year I plan to buy myself a nice 2008/2009 diesel Jaguar X Type. I owned one of these when I was last back in the UK and it was fantastic....
I've just bought a motorhome and I want to tow a small-ish car behind it (in UK). It must also act as a family car (2 adults and sometimes grandchildren). I'm quite tempted by the Ford Fiesta, Ford Focus...
Related models
Quicker and better to drive than the Jaguar Mk2
Superb blend of ride quality and enjoyable handling. Comfortable and refined. Well-equipped as standard. Available with low CO2 diesel engines.

Ask Honest John

Value my car