Which used estate is best?

I am looking to buy an estate up to three years old and up to 30k mileage. I have up to £16,000 to spend. At the moment the car would be used for mostly short journeys in stop start traffic - I do about 8k mileage a year. However, due to a change of job location coming up next year, my annual mileage will be going up to about 25k. I am considering the latest estate models of the Octavia, Cee'd, Golf and Leon.

Which of those four estates do you consider to have the best combination of safety, driving enjoyment and reliability?

Asked on 10 August 2016 by Olly Farrow

Answered by Honest John
You'll probably get 45mpg + out of a Peugeot 308 1.2 PureTech 130 estate and with 230Nm torque you won't be hanging about. Golf, Octavia and Leon has exactly the same EA288 1.6 TDI engine that so far seems to be over all the problems of the EA189 but is still belt cam leaving you with a £500-£600 maintenance job every 4 years or every 60k miles. The Kia 1.6 CRDI is a bit less economical but is chain cam, saving that £600 maintenance bill, and carries a 7 year warranty.
Tags: buying
Similar questions
Were looking to replace our Bongo camper with a nearly newish estate for around £16k. We need room for 2 young kids and a newfoundland dog who sits 85cm tall. We canoe too so estate's probably preferred...
I bought a pre-reg Skoda Scout from a main dealer. They said I would get the V5 in about 3 weeks and didn't give me the new keeper section. After 5 weeks and various phone calls and emails I phoned the...
I am in the RAF and posted to Naples in Sept. I currently have a 10 plate Skoda Octavia estate 1.6 but it isn't powerful enough to carry all my kit down and then back again in 18 months time. The car will...
Related models
Roomy. More load space than the old car. Flexible and practical. Haldex clutched 4WD Scout version.

Ask Honest John

Value my car