Which is better: Lexus IS250C or recent Lexus SC430? I like them both!

I am looking for a second car that will do 5000 miles a year.

Has to be a CC (metal roofed convertible). The SC430 has a magnificent interior and great touring performance, but is a bit ugly and is greedy.

The IS250C is modern, more funtional but is slower and a bit bland inside.

I have read your review of the IS (many thanks) and looked in great detail at both cars but, hell, I like them both!

Asked on 13 June 2012 by Hasselblad

Answered by Honest John
Definitely go for the IS250C. Used now from about £22,500.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I am considering getting a slightly more 'grown up' roadster for some time. I have a limited budget of £5000 which seems to flag up quite a few late 90's early 00's cars and was considering the Boxster,...
My budget is £2500 approx. Which 2 seater convertible would you recommend as a summer car and why?
I'm looking to buy either a Mercedes-Benz SLK or a Mazda MX-5. My budget is £2500. What are the pros and cons of both, please?
Related models
Incredibly refined. Barely any top-down turbulence. Metal-folding roof retracts smoothly. Effortless performance.
Effortlessly swift, luxurious and refined alternative to the Mercedes SL, complete with folding hard-top and first-class build quality.

Value my car