Should I be in Drive or Neutral at traffic lights?

I have a 2018 MINI Countryman auto. I've read that the gearbox allows for stopping at lights while still in Drive. But I've also read that it's best to slip into Neutral to save wear on the dual clutches. With previous Torque Converter cars, I always stayed in D but now with the MINI I select N. Your opinion, please?

Asked on 27 October 2020 by Brian Joslin

Answered by Andrew Brady
Stay in D unless you're stopped for a prolonged period. Also bear in mind that, if you're stopped with your foot on the brakes, your brake lights will be illuminated. That can be a good thing (ensuring you're seen on a quiet road, for example), but can also cause discomfort for the driver behind in traffic.
Similar questions
I've got about £8k to spend on a big auto estate - so naturally the Ford Mondeo is an option. However, I've heard bad things about Ford's double clutch Powershift gearbox - tales of it failing at low mileages...
I have an automatic Nissan Juke with a full Nissan service history which has covered 17000 miles. It's three months outside warranty and now has a gearbox problem. Nissan tell me it needs a new gearbox....
My daughter wants an automatic Volkswagen Golf about six years old. Which models have the wet clutch gearbox?
Related models
Biggest ever MINI. Upmarket and quirky interior. Good to drive. Available as a plug-in hybrid.

Ask Honest John

Value my car