When it comes to older cars, are petrol or diesel models more reliable?

I’m looking to buy an older (2004 or 2005), three-door Toyota RAV4. I had a 2-litre petrol one some time back and miss its performance and agility around my local lanes. I have heard the diesels can be troublesome, so should I buy petrol or diesel?

Asked on 17 June 2020 by Nigel

Answered by Dan Powell
Diesel engines are very expensive to fix, compared to petrol. A £3000 RAV4 diesel engine could easily cost you £1500/£2000 in repairs if it needs serious work to the DMF, EGR, turbo. I'd probably go with the petrol. At 16-years the RAV4 will be approaching the end of its mechanical life. I think you'd get better value from the petrol.
Similar questions
I’m thinking of buying a 2005 Porsche Cayenne with 90,000 miles on the clock. I’ll do barely 1500 miles per year in it. How mechanically reliable is it likely to be?
I'm considering buying either a 2007 Jaguar XJ6 with 160,000 miles or a 1998 XJ8 with 98,000 miles whilst I'm in Switzerland for 2-3 years. I'll cover approx 150 miles per day so comfort and ride enjoyment...
I just bought a 2005 Honda Accord. I took it into a Honda dealership to check the air con as it wasn't working properly. They told me that the air conditioning condenser radiator needs replacing, which...
Related models
Bigger and now 5-door only. More luxurious but not as practical as previous RAV-4. Car-like road manners. Petrol and diesel automatics. Facelifted 2010.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car