I am looking to change from having a main vehicle as a 4WD. We live 700ft up in North Wales. Currently we have an Outlander 2.0 diesel. I am considering buying an Ibiza Cupra as an everyday vehicle (if we can get one) and having a 4WD SUV as a second vehicle. The second vehicle needs to cope with driving in fields and towing a trailer full of wood. I thought about a double cab pick-up or used SUV. I have read your used car details but cannot decide. Looked at a few Mazda and L200 pick-ups and you seem to like the Isuzu pick up. I would be pleased to have any suggestions. By the way we used your often-suggested route of selling a low mileage 2000 SLK 320 manual at Sure Sell (BCA) Preston, last June. At the time most trade models of similar spec and age were making about £7,000 at trade. They suggested a limit of £5,800 but it made £7,400.

Asked on 30 January 2010 by D.S., via e-mail

Answered by Honest John
Another accolade for Sure Sell. Among pick-ups, the Isuzu D-Max/Rodeo I-TEQ 2.5 and 3.0 diesels are the best engines. Strongest, most economical, most reliable and nicest to drive. I bought two in Thailand: one in a D-Max HiLander; one in a Chevrolet Colorado. Mitsubishi L200 Tritons have the strongest and best chassis, and the best handling, but (until the ‘Long Bed’ was launched in May last year) the smallest load decks. Currently the most popular in the UK is the Nissan Navara, because it's the biggest, but it isn’t as good since it acquired a diesel particulate filter.
I’d also consider the rather ore civilised 2010 version of the Hyundai Santa Fe 2.2 diesel. Power is up to a colossal 194bhp, torque to 422Nm (more than the new Landcruiser 3.0 litre), yet fuel economy is around 40mpg by virtue of a new 6-speed manual (or 6-speed automatic) and the manual can tow 2,500kg. From £21,495.

Honest John recommends carwow – find and buy your perfect car, in just a few clicks

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I just wanted to thank you for your advice on buying and selling. I recently bought a new Audi Q5 through Drivethedeal. I got a much better discount than I could have negotiated myself, with zero hassle....
I am going to be in Scotland for the next 10 or 11 weeks. The cheapest car rental I could find is over £1,500. Should I try to buy and re-sell, or are there places that rent older cars more cheaply? I...
I have purchased a new XC90 via Drive the Deal at an excellent discount. The car is due to arrive June / July. I currently have a 2005/55 BMW 740iL with many options, full history and 49k miles. It is...
Related models
Excellent build quality, terrific engineering and a very good crash test rating. Much better drive from 2000 onwards.
Extremely tough running gear, long tyre life, durable interior, proven four-wheel drive system.
Handsome looks and plenty of kit, Mitsubishi chain cam 2.3 DI-D engine is excellent. 5 seats + 2 child seats. Very competent off-road with 4WD. Also available with 2WD.
Cheap to run. Five star Euro NCAP rating. Clear and simple dash layout. Facelifted with improved engine range from spring 2012.

Ask Honest John

Value my car