Farmer’s grand-daughter

If you had a 17 year old grand-daughter who lived out in the country (in Northumberland actually) and who had just passed her test and was hell-bent on buying a small used car with a budget of say £3,000 (give or take a bit), which 3 cars would you suggest she consider please?

Asked on 9 January 2010 by T.C., via e-mail

Answered by Honest John
Citroen C1, Peugeot 107 or Toyota Aygo. All basically the same car, but lowest for insurance, CO2 and general running costs. Insurance may be a problem. For Northumberland, NFU Mutual might be best. Government needs to intervene over the high cost of young peoples insurance where premiums of £2,000 - £5,000 are leading 30% of kids to drive uninsured. If a maximum premium of £1,000pa for cars up to Insurance Group 3 was imposed, then the ‘cost’ to other drivers would not be any greater than the amount they bear from 30% of kids driving uninsured.
Similar questions
I am returning to full time work in September and we are looking for a small, basic second car that I can use for my journey each day. My commute will be only 10 minutes each way along windy, country lanes...
My 18-year-old son has decided to take up driving lessons and will eventually have a car of his own. What would you recommend as his first car? My issue is obviously insurance costs but more importantly...
I am a 56-year-old mum with full no-claims. I am planning to buy a smallish Fiesta-size car either new or used, which my 17 year old son can practise on while learning, and can drive as an occasional user...
Related models
Cheap to run. Economical and perky 1.0-litre engine. Fun to drive. Decent cabin room. Ideal first car. 2012 model emits 99g/km CO2.
Low road tax and insurance. Averages a claimed 60mpg. Cheap to run and drives decently. 99g/km CO2 from 2012.