What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
yours for mine? - El Hacko
Several of the posts here about "what car to buy" suggest that many of us (who don't want to buy new) are genuinely not sure. You know you want to change, but to what? So how about swopping? Not sure about all the practicalities involved, but let's say you have a nice, well maintained vehicle. If (thru' this site) you post what you think you'd like to change to, then a list could be compiled quite easily. I would imagine that most posters here look after their cars, although nothing is guaranteed, of course. There would have to be cash "adjustments" for different values. Such a swop system would get round the problem of trying to sell privately - often a nightmare these days. Prospective swoppers could even have a trial period (with temporary insurance cover), altho' this could only work between people who live reasonably near each other. Yes, swopping would not suit everyone, and many regulars will come up with obstacles I haven't thought of, but one for discussion, BRs...
yours for mine? - Mapmaker
Which begs the question: 'Why do people like to change their car so often?'

yours for mine? - El Hacko
just change for change's sake, quite often - bit like a shirt or jacket, but not requiring such frequency?
yours for mine? - barney100
Used to change my cars regularly but as time goes by I am only changing when absolutely needed.
yours for mine? - Dulwich Estate
Only change mine when the manufacturer's warranty runs out. Every 3 years suits me well. But, I might get bored when they get round to 5 year warranties!
yours for mine? - Andrew-T
DE - you must believe that paying depreciation makes more sense than paying repair costs? ;o)
yours for mine? - Dulwich Estate

Big rant starting now:

I think this deserves a serious reply and maybe a thread of its own. "Making more sense" just doesn't come in to it at all. I know buying new (and from a dealer!)every 3 years does not make pure financial sense but I like new cars and like the idea of no hassle (none of this broker / internet / import stuff either).

I can afford to buy just about any car in any showroom but am constrained by town driving, town parking and also image when seeing clients. Would you employ a building firm where the boss turns up in a fancy / pricey bit of exotica to quote for your job?

Anyway, the point I want to make is that although I'm fortunate enough to be comfortably well off I get just a wee bit irritated when Back Roomers constantly refer to "makes no financial sense", "loses too much in depreciation" etc. etc.

You must like motoring to be here - just enjoy it.

I bet you didn't buy the cheapest house beacuse it was cheap - the decision was not purely price based. Which Backroomer hunts out the cheapest toilet paper, breakfast cereal, meat. Do you but the cheapest newspaper or car mag ? I think not. Hey, get yesterday's newspaper it's free.

Mind you, constant references to Lidl may mean you do.

Rant over - I feel so much better now.
yours for mine? - No Do$h
Big rant starting now:
I think this deserves a serious reply and maybe a thread
of its own. "Making more sense" just doesn't come in to
it at all. I know buying new (and from a dealer!)every
3 years does not make pure financial sense but I like
new cars and like the idea of no hassle (none of
this broker / internet / import stuff either).
I can afford to buy just about any car in any
showroom but am constrained by town driving, town parking and also
image when seeing clients. Would you employ a building firm where
the boss turns up in a fancy / pricey bit of
exotica to quote for your job?
Anyway, the point I want to make is that although I'm
fortunate enough to be comfortably well off I get just a
wee bit irritated when Back Roomers constantly refer to "makes no
financial sense", "loses too much in depreciation" etc. etc.
You must like motoring to be here - just enjoy it.
I bet you didn't buy the cheapest house beacuse it was
cheap - the decision was not purely price based. Which Backroomer
hunts out the cheapest toilet paper, breakfast cereal, meat. Do you
but the cheapest newspaper or car mag ? I think not.
Hey, get yesterday's newspaper it's free.
Mind you, constant references to Lidl may mean you do.
Rant over - I feel so much better now.


I only take issue with one point in that post. Leave Lidl alone! I chose the screen name No Dosh partly out of respect to my late father, who always pointed out that the way I handle money I would never have any cash and partly due to the fact that I'm earning a pretty good living whilst acquiring toys and gadgets like they are going out of fashion.

Despite this, I think Lidl is great! Good fresh food if you know what you are looking for and some bloomin' marvellous bargain tools in amongst all the tat and £1.99 childrens' slippers.

:o)

BTW, the "oooh, it'll cost you" mentality is driving me nuts too.
yours for mine? - Dulwich Estate
I have been misunderstood. I used the word "Lidl" as something of an euphemism for "cheap" mentality which I accept is not quite right. Lidl can offer super value - I go there very occasionally (I even know about Thursdays!).

The veg. especially when just delivered is often way beyond the quality of the supermarket giants.

Trouble is, when faced with one check-out girl and a queue 12 deep I often walk out again. Saving money is one thing - spending my time to do it is altogether another.

Quality comes in different guises it's not always "you get what you pay for".

PS I take life too seriously - my blood pressure is up and I can't relax - honest.
yours for mine? - Mapmaker
>>Trouble is, when faced with one check-out girl and a queue 12 deep I often walk out again. Saving money is one thing - spending my time to do it is altogether another.


Yup, me too. The fruit & veg at East Street market, Walworth has to be the best & cheapest around - and you don't have to queue for it. Waitrose (second choice for shopping) comes a close second on quality but not on price!


It depends what you use your car for, and how often. I'm sure I might think about running a newer car if I did 100 miles commute each way each day. If I spent that long in it, I would get annoyed with the speaker that doesn't work, for which I haven't got round to buying a replacement. If I had somewhere else to keep the car other than the public road whence I've had two cars stolen this year, then I'd at least think about running something newer (& inevitably less swanky?). But low miles, infrequent use and unhappy parking militate towards an old banger.
Building firm boss turning up in swanky car.


I wish I could find a building firm boss who would turn up in any sort of car!

yours for mine? - No Do$h
Several other contractors I know run their "nice" car at weekends and use battered old TD repmobiles for their commute. Most popular are the xantia and the mondeo.

Can't quite bring myself to do this, but may change my mind if I ever get something exotic....
yours for mine? - Mapmaker
If you'd bought that Merc you wouldn't want to run it when it rains; you'd want to keep it garaged. You wouldn't want to put loads of miles on it either - just think how often you would be adjusting the points etc. etc.

Problem with my theory is that my car is a much more comfortable drive than any Vectra (however new) I've driven.
yours for mine? - Hawesy1982
DE - By all means, if you can afford to buy brand new cars from a dealer every 3 years, then do so, it's your money.

Most BackRoomer's points about depreciation refer to the fact that the majority of people simply can't afford to/don't want to lose a large amount of money buying something that will be a rapidly depreciating asset.

Your point about which house you would buy is slightly irrelevant i think, as generally a house does not 'depreciate' in the way that a car does (unless bought brand new aswell).

But as i said at the start of this post, its your money, so do whatever you feel happiest doing
yours for mine? - Paul Robinson
Out of interest Dulwich Estate, what car do you choose that suits town driving, town parking and the boss of a building firm quoting for jobs?
yours for mine? - Dulwich Estate
New Jan 2002 - Audi A4 Avant 2.0 Multitronic Auto. Very conservative, but have since got wise to diesel so have identical car (different colour) but with 1.9Tdi 130 due for delivery 1st week September.

Ideally would like a choice of two cars - one work, one fun - but haven't got the space here in London. There's a Jazz to be accommodated too.

Forgot to mention, I also need to go about 550 miles each way to Charante, SW France every now and then.
yours for mine? - Dulwich Estate
Not sure if that reads right - maybe it does. I meant to say I am conservative in that I always thought petrol was the only means of fuelling a proper car. I thought diesel was only for vans, buses, lorries and those who were in need of saving money. Now I've driven one I'm a convert.

PS I read the Torygraph so that makes me one too.
yours for mine? - Paul Robinson
Do your customers ever remark on your choice of car?
yours for mine? - Mapmaker
Probably not as it's so 'convservative'.

But I did think that next door's builder with his convertible brand new 3 series (into which he loaded his tools) was a bit too swanky.

Similarly I would worry about a builder who drove an old Cortina. Being a builder is easy money (no offence DE I don't mean it's easy, but there's certainly lots of money in it) so one who cannot afford a semi-decent car is doing something wrong. And builders of course always do run better cars than their customers, so you expect your builder to have spent money on his car. Silly, isn't it!
yours for mine? - Dulwich Estate



Very rarely. Sometimes the occasional comment "nice car - too good for carrying tools". I don't carry tools - I'm management. Ideally I just want the car to be somewhere between invisible and "his firm are doing OK, so they're not a bad firm, but there again he's not ripping us off because it's only an Audi and not some flash car."

Time for a new thread: does you car project an image of you?. Is it a desirable one etc.
yours for mine? - patently
But anyway, to return to the subject of the thread, I think this is an idea with potential.

Ebay et al are developing as good ways to buy a new car but the perrenial problem is the lack of trade-in. OK, you can sell yours on Ebay as well but the chances of timing the sale for the same day is minimal. Assuming you need the cash from the old one to pay for the new one then that means you will need to be without wheels* for a few days.

The question is whether you would limit your choice of potential traders too much to achieve a decent exchange price.


*and heaven knows what will happen to your views on cars if you have no-wheels for that long ;-)
yours for mine? - No Do$h
*and heaven knows what will happen to your views on cars
if you have no-wheels for that long ;-)


:: smirk ::
yours for mine? - NowWheels
>> *and heaven knows what will happen to your views on
cars
>> if you have no-wheels for that long ;-)
:: smirk ::


Don't worry, I can confirm from prolonged experience that it doesn't lead to any desire to drive mediterranean tractors, or to make friends with flatbed trucks.

:: my turn to smirk ::
yours for mine? - Mapmaker
>>>I think this is an idea with potential.


OK, you're on.
yours for mine? - patently
>>>I think this is an idea with potential.
OK, you're on.


Quote from original suggestion:

"There would have to be cash "adjustments" for different values."
yours for mine? - Mapmaker
Yes we agreed this in the thread last week when you stood me up in the King's. I suggested the values were equal, but you said yours was worth much less than mine...

yours for mine? - patently
you stood me up in the King's.


Me!!!!! We said you'd come to Oxfordshire! I'm so hurt...
I suggested the values
were equal, but you said yours was worth much less than
mine...


Oh, you mean that one. When can you make it up here then?
yours for mine? - Mapmaker
I'll drive mine up anytime so long as you guarantee that I'll be able to drive back in yours...
yours for mine? - patently
How tall are you?

Over 3", there might be a problem.
yours for mine? - just a bloke
I have practical experience of swopping.

When I went to view my spider I went in my GTV it turned out that the couple who were selling the spider were nitending to replace it with a GTV.

We agreed terms and a week later met on neutral territory and swopped our cars.

This worked out well for both of us. Saved me the bother of selling the GTV, saved them the bother of looking for one.

JaB

yours for mine? - sorrera
Ok I \'ll give it a go
Willing to swap 1999 V 2.5 TDI Audi A4 Quattro saloon 140K miles in silver Tiptronic, semi automatic.
Full Service history, very good condition. Serviced 150 miles ago.
Usual quattro extras plus an MP3/ CD player (original Cassette unit also available)

Telegraph motoring site gives mileage adjusted, excellent condition value at £6640. tinyurl.com/5onaz

Whatcar gives private valuation at £8,333 mileage adjusted.
www.whatcar.co.uk/Valuations_Result.asp?MA=6&MV=24...0

Looking for
Slightly larger car, e.g. Audi A6, 5 series of similar age/ mileage. Manual preferred. Diesel would be nice but not a deal breaker.
Naturally would be looking for one of similar values as quoted above.

Central Scotland but I\'m up for a 1/2 way meet for the right deal.

So anyone??
yours for mine? - Kevin
I've got a Lada Riva.

Willing to swap for Continental GT, DB9 or similar ;-)

Kevin...
yours for mine? - ratty
Sounds a good idea.

How many people would be willing to pay a fee or commission for a successful swap ... eg. to this website. I would for one.