Why is the same insurance company quoting different renewal prices on different comparison sites?

I've just been on two comparison websites to look for cheaper car insurance than my latest renewal quote. A company quotes £186 on one site and £165 on another for the same level of cover. Why is there such a difference?

Asked on 29 August 2017 by

Answered by Tim Kelly
It could be the profit margin the website operates with, they will receive a commission for selling. £20 difference is virtually nothing. You can easily find the same and see differences of many hundreds of pounds. It always pays to do as you have done, but I would also read all the contract because there may be a difference you have not spotted.
Similar questions
My car insurance broker, Swinton, issued me with a letter to confirm that in July last year (2016) I had 12 years of no claims. Aviva who I insured with last year only go up to nine years NCD, so that's...
Is it usual for insurers to charge if you install a dashcam? I'm insured with Admiral and told them I was thinking of installing a dashcam and wondered if this would bring a discount when renewing my insurance....
I recently hired a car in Spain and during the rental I had a flat tyre. The rental firm charged me 125 Euros when I returned the car. Fortunately, I had taken out separate car hire excess insurance before...

Ask Honest John

Value my car