What crossover should we get for £22,000 after our 2006 Honda Civic?

We're looking at changing our 2006 1.8 i-VTEC Honda Civic for a new crossover and would appreciate your view. Most journeys are 5 miles or less, with longer motorway runs several times a year, so we're looking at petrol and manual to keep long term. Budget is about £22,000, and on the short list so far: Honda H-RV (SE), Kia Sportage ("2") and Suzuki S-Cross SX4 (SZ5).

We've ruled out the Seat Ateca, Toyota C-HR, Hyundai Tucson and the Suzuki Vitara S (as we prefer the S-Cross SZ5 with the same engine). Are there any others we should seriously consider, like the Mazda CX-5, or the 2017 Peugeot 3008? Both the Honda (engine/gearing for motorway use) and the Kia (fuel economy looks poor?) seem to have down sides so we're not sure which way to go.

Asked on 30 December 2016 by S mbrose

Answered by Honest John
Not a Honda HR-V 1.5 i-VTEC manual. Needs the 1.8 i-VTEC and doesn't get it. The KIA Sportage 1.6 T GDI GT is brilliant, but about £4000 over budget. I can't stand the sight of the hideous Suzuki S-Cross and can't see the point of it. I'd go for the Vitara S 1.4 T BoosterJet any day. The SEAT Ateca with 1.0 TSI or (better) the 1.4 TSI is actually very good to drive. The Toyota C-HR 1.2 iVVTI has the best ride and handling of any SUV on the planet. A Hyundai Tucson is the same thing as a KIA Sportage with different styling. New Mazda CX-5 coming next year so better to wait. A Peugeot 2008 GT with the 1.2 PureTech 130 engine, 6-speed box and Grip Control drives and rides better than a Vitara S. The 3008 with the same powertrain is a bit over budget. But well under budget is a Dacia Duster 1.2 TCe 125 4x4 at £14,895 (+£450 if you want satnav). Most if not all are comprehensively tested at www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/
Similar questions
My parents are looking to replace their trusty 2003 Honda Civic with something a bit more up to date. They've tried the new Civic but complain it's too low for their aged knees. They are considering the...
We have a 2014 Land Rover Freelander (15,000 miles) and a 2013 Kia Rio (22,000) on 17-inch rims (big mistake for country roads). We have a budget of about £20,000 and would like to change the Kia Rio for...
I recently had the 'restricted performance' limitation appear on my 2013 diesel Land Rover Evoque (it has done 35,000 miles). I stopped and switched off, waited a short while, then restarted and it had...
Related models
Practical and comfortable cabin, huge amounts in interior space, great 2.2 i-CTDi diesel engine, well built and reliable, enjoyable to drive.
Exceptional value for money – an SUV for the price of a small hatch, low running costs, hugely practical, large boot and spacious cabin.
Excellent 1.2-litre PureTech petrol engine, more spacious and practical than the 208, post-facelift version looks smart.
Highly practical and versatile thanks to 'magic' seats. Strong i-DTEC diesel.
Good value for money. Handles well. Strong and economical 120PS 1.6 petrol engine. SZ4 is very well equipped.
Outstanding ride, road holding and handling. A pleasure to drive. 1.2 petrol or 1.8 hybrid. Solid build quality. More power and performance from 184PS 2.0 C-HR from January 2020. Apple CarPlay and Android Auto now standard.
Very good to drive and comfortable. Lots of interior space. Five star Euro NCAP rating. Relatively economical. Excellent 1.0 BoosterJet engines.
More refined than ix35. Cabin is spacious and comfortable. Lots of family appeal with affordable running costs and huge boot. Five star Euro NCAP rating.
One of the best crossovers on the market, well-equipped, seven-year warranty, practical and spacious.
Very comfortable and refined with impressive ride quality. Lots of room for those in the back along with a large boot. Good value for money. 1.6 TDI should prove very economical. Five star Euro NCAP rating.
Well-finished, stylish cabin. Well-equipped as standard. Full-colour digital instruments on all models.
Enjoyable to drive, head-turning looks, upmarket interior.


Value my car