Do hybrids perform well for high-mileage drivers?

My lease car is due for renewal through my NHS leasing scheme. At the moment, I have a diesel Kia Ce'ed, for which I pay £105 per month. Prices have increased and the same car will cost me £165 next time, which is disappointing. I do approximately 250,000 miles annually, mainly on dual carriageways as my work area spans East Anglia. I'd had my eye on a Kia Niro in the hope that I could go greener, but everything I read suggests that hybrids aren't suitable for high milers. It costs £20 more per month to lease a Niro, which I thought I may get back by filling up less regularly, but is this likely? If not, are there any other hybrids that would be better? If not, I'm veering towards a SEAT Leon as this costs the same as a replacement Cee'd or a Ford Focus. Is a diesel still a better option than petrol?

Asked on 30 May 2017 by Nicky Srahan

Answered by Simon Harris
I can see why you're looking for an alternative with such a big jump in your monthly payments. But you are also right in that hybrids tend to work less well for high-mileage drivers, being best suited to running on electric for short distances around towns and cities, using the engine and braking to charge the battery as necessary. According to our Real MPG database, a diesel Cee'd typically returns around 70 per cent of the official combined cycle fuel consumption figure, with 74 per cent for the Niro. But you should probably bear in mind that drivers who have entered data on the Niro have chosen it because the hybrid technology is well suited to their driving needs. Hybrids have improved in the latest generation of models to perform better in the real world, so you should probably look at the latest Toyota Prius (also check the Our Cars section of our website as we've been running one of these for a few months), and possibly the Hyundai Ioniq Hybrid. The Ioniq uses the same engine and hybrid system as the Niro, but if you don't need the SUV body style, it might save you a little in fuel through its improved aerodynamics - which become a bigger factor at higher speeds, such as on dual carriageways. The SEAT Leon diesel is a very good car and should perform well as a 25,000-miles-a-year company vehicle, but I would also look at the latest Vauxhall Astra and Peugeot 308, which should perform equally well, to check if they would save you any more money than the Leon each month.
Similar questions
I'm currently running a 2009 Volkswagen Golf Plus 2.0 TDI that I've had for almost five trouble-free years. It'll be at 90,000 miles soon and I think I should get out before I have to spend money on it....
I currently drive a 2011 Fiat Bravo Multijet diesel - I bought it for the MPG and it hasn't disappointed in that regard, although it's irritatingly unreliable and handling isn't great. Despite living in...
I currently drive a 2007 diesel Hyundai Tucson auto. It's done 190,000 miles and is in need of replacing. I do about 25,000 miles a year, mostly country roads and motorways, and want something with good...
Related models
Big improvements in quality and refinement over previous Leon. Great to drive with sharp handling. Good value. Shares same base as latest A3 and Golf.
Impressive value for money and plenty of standard equipment, later T-GDI petrol engine offers impressive performance and economy, seven-year warranty.
Some truly brilliant engine choices including impressive 1.2 Puretech petrol, large family-friendly boot, interior looks and feels posh, five star Euro NCAP rating.
Relaxed but still enjoyable to drive, well-equipped for the money, a huge choice on the used market.
Solid all-rounder that’s good in all areas, cheap to run, excellent value as a used car and loads around, five star Euro NCAP rating.
Low emissions of 70g/km. Relaxed, quiet and comfortable. Spacious cabin. Lots of safety kit as standard. TNGA platform provides excellent ride, handling and steering.
Available as hybrid, plug-in or pure EV. Easy and relaxing to drive. Low running costs.
Easy to drive. Impressive fuel economy and low running costs. Space for a family. 450 litre load area.

Value my car