Used Audi Q3 or new SEAT Ateca?

I am in the market for a compact SUV due to our one year old labrador out growing our Volkswagen Scirocco. I've narrowed my list to two: the Audi Q3 or SEAT Ateca. Both will be 2.0 diesels with the DSG automatic gearbox.

I have yet to test drive either and my budget is £23k, which means the Q3 would be a 2013 or 2014 model. I'm drawn to the Q3 in S-Line trim but fear the suspension will be too harsh for the bumpy country roads where we live. Any thoughts on which might be the better bet?

Asked on 12 October 2016 by David

Answered by Honest John
Makes far more sense to buy the new Ateca. Ironically, the Q3 is built by SEAT in Martorell, but the Ateca is built by Skoda in the Czech Republic.
Similar questions
Has Volkswagen/Skoda improved their DSG box to prevent reliability problems? I am about to order a new Yeti 1.2 with the DSG box.
In your review of the SEAT Ateca you refer to possible lag with the petrol/auto combination. I've driven a manual Ateca which is good in all respects. Should I be concerned about ordering an auto. What...
I am looking to buy a new Kia Sportage petrol with the seven-speed DSG gearbox. However, a friend of mine has told me to avoid this car because it uses Volkswagen's DSG gearbox. The Kia salesman states...
Related models
Stylish. compact SUV in a similar fashion to the Range Rover Evoque. Impressive fuel economy and low CO2. Two and four-wheel drive available.
Very comfortable and refined with impressive ride quality. Lots of room for those in the back along with a large boot. Good value for money. 1.6 TDI should prove very economical. Five star Euro NCAP rating.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car