Coronavirus COVID-19: Advice on buying, owning and running a car during the outbreak | No thanks

I bought a car with a faulty battery - is the dealer liable?

I purchased my used 2009 Volkswagen Beetle Cabriolet five months ago. After returning from a two-week holiday the battery was dead. The RAC told me there is a fault with the battery and it was not taking charge. I contacted the Volkswagen dealer who tells me it is not covered under my extended warranty and, at their extensive four-point check, it had no issues.

I recall at the time of test driving that the salesman was unable to show me how to close the roof as he had apparently left the window down, running down the battery. I queried this at the time and he told me that they would check the battery and replace it, if necessary, before I collected.

The VW dealer promised a callback from the brand manager, but I haven't had the call. Where do I stand on this in view of the short time I have had the car and, in hindsight, the apparently coincidental issue at the time of the test drive?

Asked on by

Under the Supreme Court ruling in Clegg v Olle Anderson (trading as Nordic Marine) 2003, the selling dealer is liable to replace the battery because it was "not of satisfactory quality" on the date of sale by being incapable of holding a full charge of 13.5 volts. The irrefutable proof of this is that the battery was too run down to power the roof on the day of your test drive.
Similar questions
I bought a 2007 Audi A4 TDI ten months ago with 25,000 on the clock and a 12-month Audi warranty. When setting off in first gear it intermittently judders, particularly when the engine is cold and on hill...
I bought a car in November 2019 but didn't receive a three-month warranty paperwork from the used car dealer. The engine was making a ticking noise but the dealer just said it was the turbo. Since then...
I bought a ten year old Ford Ranger from a dealer seven months ago, with a three month warranty. The timing belt went last week and the dealer's own mechanic fitted a new one just before we bought it....
Related models
Evocative styling and Golf MkIV underpinnings. Better handling from 2002 model year onwards. V5 is a hoot to drive.

Ask Honest John

Value my car