Can you recommend an economical, safe lease car for use as a city commuter?

I presently lease a Nissan Micra Tekna through the NHS trust l work for. The trust will not be undertaking any further leasing agreements when mine runs out in June 2011. I have decided to take on a personal lease and have been doing some research of suitable cars but find the sheer volume of information confusing. l do a lot of city stop-start driving including commuting, plus some short journeys throughout the day and some motorway driving once monthly.

Basically, my requirements are safety, low running costs (i.e. 55mpg or more), style and cost (no more than £11,000). A 3-door would be fine unless the car is very small, and I need a boot that could accommodate a buggy. I also need to take a child car seat in the back as a fairly permanent fixture. I am considering the Toyota Aygo 5-door, Citroen C1 or C3. Any other suggestions? I would not consider another Micra. Although comfy, I found it quite heavy on petrol and that other drivers appear to treat Micra drivers like idiots.

Asked on 2 October 2010 by S.L., via email

Answered by Honest John
The cars you list make sense as basic transport, plus the very similar Nissan Pixo and Suzuki Alto. Also consider a Suzuki Splash 1.0 for low tax and an upright driving position, the new Hyundai i10 1.0 Kappa for £0 tax, and the new FIAT 500 TwinAir, also £0 tax. However, though the 500 TwinAir is only 95g/km CO2, there are doubts that it is as fuel efficient as this implies, because it develops very little torque at low revs, necessitating third gear for 30mph and relatively high revs.
Similar questions
Our main car is a Volkswagen Touran. We require a second car primarily as a local runabout. We’re looking for something cost effective in fuel and insurance, around 12-18 months old from Motorpoint in...
My chairman at work suggested you might be able to give me some good advice on buying a car. I’d like to buy a small, economical car and have a budget of £8000. I live in central London so don’t drive...
I am returning to full time work in September and we are looking for a small, basic second car that I can use for my journey each day. My commute will be only 10 minutes each way along windy, country lanes...
Related models
Cheap to run. Group 1 insurance. 60mpg. handles well. Low list prices. Good Euro NCAP score. 2012 model emits just 99g/km CO2.
Neat looking small hatchback. Uses some of the same engines as MINI. 1.6 HDi is the best in the range. Excellent ride quality.
Stylish and full of character. Really affordable to buy. Low running costs.
Cheap to buy new, low CO2 emissions and high economy mean it's cheap to run. Available with an automatic gearbox. Nicer seats than near identical Suzuki Alto.
Cute little small hatch clone offering low emissions, low tax, good fuel economy and a proper 4-speed automatic option. Decent to drive.
Small yet tall five-door city car. High seating position. Rear seats fold flat. Auto is 4-speed torque converter. Highest first time MoT pass rate of any car.
Low road tax and insurance. Averages a claimed 60mpg. Cheap to run and drives decently. 99g/km CO2 from 2012.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer