New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Warning

I was given a 2025 Ford Kuga Plug-in Hybrid as a rental car. It's nice enough, but it definitely feels heavy and not very nimble. I'm not sure if that's because the hybrid battery was fully depleted, maybe the electric assist wasn’t kicking in? Should it have recharged itself? Hard to tell what the car is doing? Perhaps I just didn’t figure out how to operate it properly.

HJ claims it’s a nimble car, but I’m not sure I agree.

I don’t want to mislead anyone, it’s not a bad car, but it feels just like every other modern car. I remember cars from the late 1990s being fun to drive. That thrill seems to be missing these days. Getting into a car feels for a journey, feels more like a chore than something enjoyable.

I’m not sure if this is because of the SUV style, large tyres and if car manufacturers are just making heavier, bulkier vehicles in general.

Cars also getting bigger and a pain to park.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Adampr

I think I've driven five PHEVs and the only one that felt 'right' was a Renault Captur. All of others felt a bit heavy and ponderous. It's a shame, because I like the PHEV concept, but I think manufacturers see them as a bit of a short term thing so don't really bother getting them right.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - badbusdriver

I would absolutely complain (if you haven't already) about being given a PHEV as a hire car with a flat battery!. Very poor show, if they aren't going to supply PHEV's charged, they should stick to HEV's or MHEV's.

Yes, a PHEV will use brake regen to put power back in the battery in the same way a HEV does, but because its battery is so big (relative to a HEV), you'd never get more than a very small percentage of charge back in. The battery on a HEV is much smaller and designed to discharge its power and recuperate it quickly.

If HJ says the Kuga is nimble, I suspect that may be relative to other PHEV SUV's (as traditionally Fords do tend to handle pretty well). But I doubt I'd class the (circa 1850kg) Kuga PHEV as nimble!. I believe they mustered 225bhp originally or 243bhp now (presumably a facelift), so should be reasonably swift in a straight line with power in the battery (but that has nowt to do with nimbleness). Not sure what the power is using only the ICE, but I'd guess maybe 170(ish)bhp, which isn't that much to be lugging around all that weight.

Edited by badbusdriver on 17/07/2025 at 19:25

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - John F

But I doubt I'd class the (circa 1850kg) Kuga PHEV as nimble!. I believe they mustered 225bhp originally or 243bhp now (presumably a facelift),.......

For a heavy car to be nimble on a twisty hilly road, it needs lots of power and four wheel drive to use it. This electro-mechanical lump has neither. Astonishingly, it is only two obese passengers short of the quoted kerb weight of my heavy, but very nimble, Audi A8 (2035Kg - 4WD -450hp).

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Andrew-T

<< ... it is only two obese passengers short of the quoted kerb weight of my heavy, but very nimble, Audi A8 (2035Kg - 4WD -450hp).>>

I am still staggered by the kerb weight of today's cars - which have become obese like some of their passengers, partly because of extra weight added to limit damage to the occupants. One of the classic 'enjoyable to drive' cars was (and still is for some) a Pug 205 GTi. The heavier of those, with the 1,9 engine, weighed 880 kilos at the kerb, the same as the diesel model. Luckily, the makers could spend a lot on improving fuel consumption to compensate for the steady growth in weight. So we have ended up roughly where we started, except that those cars take up more road space and have become unenjoyable to drive .... :-(

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - badbusdriver

But I doubt I'd class the (circa 1850kg) Kuga PHEV as nimble!. I believe they mustered 225bhp originally or 243bhp now (presumably a facelift),.......

For a heavy car to be nimble on a twisty hilly road, it needs lots of power and four wheel drive to use it. This electro-mechanical lump has neither. Astonishingly, it is only two obese passengers short of the quoted kerb weight of my heavy, but very nimble, Audi A8 (2035Kg - 4WD -450hp).

Not that astonishing given the size of the Kuga (footprint is only circa 11% less than your A8) and the fact that is carrying a 14kWh battery and electric motor in addition to its (2.5) ICE and auto transmission.

I guess nimble is a relative term here. On the type of roads I wish for nimbleness, an A8 would simply be too big, regardless of how much power or driven wheels!

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Big John

I remember cars from the late 1990s being fun to drive. That thrill seems to be missing these days. Getting into a car feels for a journey, feels more like a chore than something enjoyable.

Interesting - I've found the opposite. I bought my Swace which uses gen 5 Toyota HEV (not PHEV) gubbins and wasn't expecting to find it "fun". You know what on twisty roads up and down hills it really puts a smile on your face. Even though it has a good ride the handing is surprisingly good and that's before the slingshot exiting a corner where petrol power combines with electric as you power out of the corner. It might be because it's a low car though with a low centre of gravity. In this car the hybrid batteries are located under the back seat - obviously much smaller than for a PHEV.

In 1996 I can't remember my 1990 1.6td Passat Estate being fun although I had a 1989 1.3 Astra for a while and yes I suppose that was ok. The last Escort produced wasn't fun at all but the first version of the Ford Focus was.

Edited by Big John on 17/07/2025 at 20:40

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Ethan Edwards

Maybe I'm weird but try a little EV a Fiat500e. Absolute hoot, little go kart. Bags of get up n go.

I've just signed up for an MG4 coming end of the year ( factory order). Just done a test drive but that was pretty nimble too, despite being 1.7t.

It's because the C of G is so low on an EV. Eats up the battery though.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Adampr

I remember cars from the late 1990s being fun to drive. That thrill seems to be missing these days. Getting into a car feels for a journey, feels more like a chore than something enjoyable.

Interesting - I've found the opposite. I bought my Swace which uses gen 5 Toyota HEV (not PHEV) gubbins and wasn't expecting to find it "fun". You know what on twisty roads up and down hills it really puts a smile on your face. Even though it has a good ride the handing is surprisingly good and that's before the slingshot exiting a corner where petrol power combines with electric as you power out of the corner. It might be because it's a low car though with a low centre of gravity. In this car the hybrid batteries are located under the back seat - obviously much smaller than for a PHEV.

In 1996 I can't remember my 1990 1.6td Passat Estate being fun although I had a 1989 1.3 Astra for a while and yes I suppose that was ok. The last Escort produced wasn't fun at all but the first version of the Ford Focus was.

I think you're right. Possibly because automatic gearboxes are now good. You used to have the choice of an auto that was incredibly slow or a manual that meant you had to have a hand free for changing gear. These days, you can hold on with both hands, point and fire.

Our little twingo (manual) is a great laugh too, though. I suppose pretty much everything having turbos or electric assistance has made it more fun.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Robert J.

I wonder if the hire company got a load of PHEV Kugas cheap?

Over on a Lexus forum I follow there was a thread running regarding an on-line broker who was heavily discounting the PHEV version of a Lexus SUV which meant it was actually cheaper than the non-plug in version. The consensus was it was something to do with the mandated EV sales; apparently PHEV could be given a partial credit so they were given a big incentive. And wasn’t there a post on here sometime ago where company car drivers were leasing PHEV for some tax benefit and the charging leads were still sealed in the original bag on the vehicles return?

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Adampr

I wonder if the hire company got a load of PHEV Kugas cheap?

Over on a Lexus forum I follow there was a thread running regarding an on-line broker who was heavily discounting the PHEV version of a Lexus SUV which meant it was actually cheaper than the non-plug in version. The consensus was it was something to do with the mandated EV sales; apparently PHEV could be given a partial credit so they were given a big incentive. And wasn’t there a post on here sometime ago where company car drivers were leasing PHEV for some tax benefit and the charging leads were still sealed in the original bag on the vehicles return?

One of the PHEVs I've driven was a Kia Xceed hire car in Spain. I could either have that or an EV (I didn't ask what but I wouldn't be near a charger). I think you're probably correct. It was charged when I got it, but I presume they were being sold cheap to hire companies to get the numbers up.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Orb>>.

I can not think of a car in the past many years that has been enjoyable to drive. Comfortable, some, economical some. but in today’s traffic conditions fun/enjoyable... NO ! It's there to do a job of A to B.

Cars are all white goods now and with age and lack of parts sometimes irreparable

JLR say the Ingenium engine has a service life of 8 years. People could not get parts for the SAIC MG 6 quite early on. Many many makers have back order lists for seemingly common parts.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - John F

I can not think of a car in the past many years that has been enjoyable to drive.

Can I suggest Mrs F's Pug 2008? At much the same size, weight and power, it reminds me of my Dolly Sprint of c.50yrs ago - a hoot of a car. Looking over its low set small steering wheel it's like driving a go-cart. Such fun.....especially when, ahem, Mrs F is elsewhere.

JLR say the Ingenium engine has a service life of 8 years.

I would think by that time this problematic engine would resemble Trigger's broom. 8 years is 70,080 hours. Assuming an average speed of 35mph that's around 250,000 miles.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Adampr

Can I suggest Mrs F's Pug 2008? At much the same size, weight and power, it reminds me of my Dolly Sprint of c.50yrs ago

I thought it had been pretty reliable so far :D

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Terry W

Most folk, unlike contributors to motoring forums, don't want cars that are fun.

They want cheap, comfortable, quiet, gizmo laden etc. Climate control and media systems far outweigh handling dynamics. Congestion limits fun opportunities - the capacity for 0-60 in sub 5 seconds never really gets tested, taking corners with 0.8G gets you labelled a nutter.

Want fun - buy something built for fun. It may be noisy, uncomfortable, basic. Doesn't need a lot of power - fun is getting the most from limited performance and skinny tyres, not going easy with the right foot for fear of unleashing 400bhp on a sharp bend.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Orb>>.

One neighbour has a Ford Anglia rally spec with a 2 litre Cosworth stuffed in it. That's one of his fun cars. The other fun car is a Sunbeam alpine Tiger with an uprated fuel injection v8 in it, but not the original one.

He won't let anyone else drive them.

For day ti day he has a c class 2008 diesel that does the job and an Old Nissan as a tip car.

He's a widower and no one to leave anything too. His sister has orders to sell only to an enthusiast.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - mcb100
Not sure I agree - Renault 5 is a hoot to drive.

It’s quicker cousin, the Alpine A290, even more so.
New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - mcb100
‘ I guess nimble is a relative term here. On the type of roads I wish for nimbleness, an A8 would simply be too big, regardless of how much power or driven wheels!’

I suspect a couple of different interpretations of the word ‘nimble’.

A very large saloon with all-wheel drive is, to my mind, the very antithesis of nimble.
The ability to change direction quickly, to have steering that is responsive and full of feel, instant throttle response - these are my criteria for a ‘nimble’ car.

They require neither a lot of power or a lot of grip - these Toyota GT86 has 200 brake, so not breaking any 0-60 records, shares energy saving tyres with a Prius, so it doesn’t have buckets full of grip, but on the road it’s a delight. It’s slideable (and catchable) if the mood takes one, and probably one of the best handling cars of the past 20 years.

By contrast, I spent a few hours driving an Aston Martin Vanquish recently - 835PS and RWD. Quite frankly terrifying to drive - even with the traction in ‘Wet’ mode it would do its best to spit you off the road. Anything but nimble.
New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - skidpan

I owned 2 Golf GTi Mk2 1.8 8 valves from 1986 to 1986. During those 10 years I covered about 160,000 miles and I enjoyed every one of them. 185 60 14 tyres and 112 bhp, seems puny compared to the willey waving number manufacturers insist we need in todays GTi's. Kerb weight was quoted as 960 kg. On the roads you could enjoy the performance with no cameras to worry about, just the occasional bobby with a speed gun lurking in a bush to be aware of.

Then in 2018 the wife got a Fabia 1.0 TSi 110 PS. Pretty much the same size as the Mk2 Golf, very close on power but it weighed more, 1055 kg according to the price list. But what it did have was 148 torques at 1900 to 3500 rpm instead of the 112 torques at 4000 rpm in the Golf. It also had 45 profile tyres which never make any car better IMHO.

Like Golf the Fabia was a hoot to drive, keep the revs above 2000 and no turbo lag and power all the way to the red line, brilliant.

The Fabia also averaged about 48 mpg over the almost 6 years we had it, never recorded the figures for the Golf but doubt if they were any better than the low 30's.

Both very enjoyable cars in which you could exploit the performance safely.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Big John

I owned 2 Golf GTi Mk2 1.8 8 valves from 1986 to 1986. #

The Golf gti of that era was a ground breaker car when you compared to other car available at the time.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - Brit_in_Germany

If the Ford is like our Mercedes PHEV, then the sporty characteristics are only present if the drive battery has enough charge. I would normally switch to sport mode when the battery has about 10% charge left. That means that power is available for the electric motor if needed and with normal driving the stored charge will incease through braking or hill descents with cruise control engaged.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - gordonbennet

To me enjoyable driving is effortless comfortable insulated driving at any speed on any and every surface, with adequate easy power on tap good all round visibility (that alone rules 90% of moderns out) and without any inferfering nannying from the vehicle.

New Cars - Not enjoyable to drive? - badbusdriver

To me enjoyable driving is effortless comfortable insulated driving at any speed on any and every surface, with adequate easy power on tap good all round visibility (that alone rules 90% of moderns out) and without any inferfering nannying from the vehicle.

Good point GB, different people are going to find driving enjoyment In different ways. Indeed the same person may derive driving enjoyment in different ways for different cars and/or on different roads.

When I worked at a VW dealer in the early noughties, one of the body shops we used was a few miles out a back road from Peterhead, twisty, undulating and barely wide enough for two cars to pass. Now John F's 450bhp 4wd super saloon would be utterly hopeless, but an original shape Ford Ka with 380bhp less, would be an absolutely blast!.

A decade earlier I was working at a Saab dealer when the 9000 2.3 turbo was introduced, cumulating in the 9000 CS Aero. Handling was OK, if well short of a contemporary 5 Series Beemer, but the enjoyment to be had deploying that sledgehammer torque was off the scale. Overtaking opportunities opened up pretty much anywhere and was guaranteed to put a smile on your face!. But enjoyment is enjoyment, right?.

Few would consider my recently departed Piaggio Porter mini truck as enjoyable to drive, but I found it very much so for two very different reasons. First is that people would smile and wave when they saw it, it just seemed to bring happiness to others, which in turn cheered me up (enjoyment?). Second is, despite what you'd thing looking at it, it was great fun to hustle along narrow twisty roads. Didn't have a lot of power (64bhp), but it didn't weigh much, was low geared, quite torquey and it was also very narrow. So you could carry a lot more speed through corners that you'd expect by taking similar lines to a motorbike (while still staying on your side of the road) and I lost count of the times I'd drop the huge modern SUV that had been tailgating me when we got to some twisties.......!

When I was driving buses, I'd take enjoyment from driving as smoothly as possible. Not as easy as you may think when many of the buses were knackered with grabby brakes and jerky gear changes!.

I'd guess some drivers derive enjoyment from maximising their efficiency, particularly so if driving a hybrid or EV?