Should my daughter buy a Kia Cerato or Citroen Picasso?

My daughter has just started teaching in Manchester, a daily return trip of 75 miles per day, 70 miles of which is motorway driving. We would like to replace her 1995 306 Peugeot XLD, which has just had a new cam belt and some other parts, and have seen the following two vehicles - a 2005 Kia Cerato 1.6 CRDI GS with 16,000 miles at £4450, and a 2004 Citroen Picasso 1.6 HDI with 15,000 miles at £4650. Both vehicles have full service history and are one-owner vehicles. They will both allow us at least £500 in part exchange for the Peugeot. What do you think?

Asked on 12 September 2010 by John Troughton

Answered by Honest John
The Cerato was not a big enough seller to be sure of a decent parts supply. If the Picasso is a 90 it's a better bet than a 110 because it won't have a DPF that will give out at between 80,000 miles and 120,000 miles. But because you have just spent good money on the 306 and because it's worth virtually nothing, I would use it up before shelling out on a newer car. If something big fails, just scrap it and then move one without having to part-exchange.
Similar questions
I currently run a 52-plate Volvo S60 2.0L petrol with 110,000 miles on the clock and with its MOT due. It's been a good runner and I picked it up five years ago. Now I'm getting itchy feet and contemplating...
I am planning on buying a car for my partner and we were looking at 2008-2010 Hyundai i30 1.6 diesel with less than 40,000 miles. Any good and bad pointers or advice on this one? He will be mostly doing...
I commute 160 motorway miles a day to and from work, and currently drive a 2004 Vectra 2.0DTi. It's an ok car, it seems happy enough to do 70mph in a straight line and, in return, gives me 47mpg consistently....
Related models
Versatile five-seat cabin with a 500-litre boot, plenty of clever touches inside, easy to fold rear seats, comfortable ride, decent value for money.
 

Value my car