Should I buy a new Toyota or used MINI with 20,000 miles?

Which car is the better buy, in terms of reliability and resale value - a new Toyota Aygo or a MINI One with 20,000 miles on the clock?

Asked on 19 December 2016 by kate tomlins

Answered by Honest John
The Aygo, because it's a Toyota and because it comes with a 5 year warranty. Not as much fun to drive, though.
Similar questions
I want to buy a new car via the scrappage schemes. I need a boot of about 350 litres, which brings my final choice down to the Renault Clio or Kia Rio. Which is the better built car and, doing 10,000 miles...
Is it better to buy a three year old car with lower mileage or a one - two year old car with higher mileage?
After the lockdown is over, I am going to buy my final new car. I want a Ford Focus-sized hatchback, petrol, automatic with good reliability and a decent warranty. I know it's a crowded market, but do...
Related models
More refined and better steering feel, much more fun to drive than previous MINI, excellent engines.
Plenty of kit as standard. Quirky looks.
 

Value my car