Can I reject my Mercedes-Benz C-Class because it doesn't match quoted fuel economy figures?

I cannot achieve Mercedes-Benz's quoted fuel consumption figures for my new C250 CDi. Despite many of my trips being long distance, the average fuel consumption is 34mpg. Mercedes-Benz specification lists Urban 34.0mpg, Combined 46.3mpg and Extra Urban 58.9mpg. The reason for purchasing the car in the first place was to improve fuel consumption. Can I reject the vehicle?

Asked on 30 July 2010 by bath604

Answered by Dan Harrison
Firstly, how many miles has the car covered? An engine will still be tight up to 5000 miles and won't be delivering optimum fuel economy. Generally, fuel economy will improve during the first 10,000 miles as the engine loosens up.

Secondly, the fuel consumption test is not a guarantee of of what you can expect. It's there to enable buyers to compare the fuel consumption of similar cars on a like-by-like basis. The tests are carried out on a rolling road in laboratory conditions and some drivers find it difficult to replicate the results in real-world conditions. Others find it easy.

Fuel consumption depends on a range of variables, including driving style, terrain, weather, weight of the vehicle etc. In short, not being able to match the official figures is not grounds for rejecting the car.
Similar questions
Last September I replaced my C220CDi Mercedes-Benz Estate (85,000 miles) with a Blue Efficiency C200 CDi Mercedes Estate – both diesel automatics. Over the life of my old car I averaged about 37mpg and...
I recently bought a secondhand 2009 Insignia 2.0 CDTI SE to replace my 2001 Toyota Avensis 1.8 VVTI. I hoped to improve fuel economy with my change in car. The Insignia, which is a diesel, has only just...
I am looking to purchase a 3-4 year old car. What is the best petrol vehicle that provides 55 miles to the gallon?
Related models
A big improvement on the previous C-Class. Feels well built and robust. Very comfortable and refined. High quality ride. Good CDI diesels.