Buying a hatchback - Golf or A3?

I want to buy a new car. Must be automatic and petrol. I quite like the Audi A3 sports back (150PS) and the Volkswagen Golf Match Editon DSG 125PS.

Both options have navigation and leather. Both are £21500. What in your view is the better car and which will have the greatest residual value in three years in your opinion?

Asked on 5 May 2016 by 612 forever

Answered by Honest John
We don't recommend either of these because they have DSG transmissions and these have been too much trouble generally. The cars themselves are fine as manuals. The 150PS is the better engine, and the A3 should have fully independent rear suspension, whereas the Golf will not have.
Similar questions
I note that Volkswagen have replaced the 1.4 TSI engine in the latest Golf with a 1.5 TSI engine, but Audi have retained the 1.4 TSI engine. How does the 1.5 TSI engine compare to the 1.4 TSI engine? I...
Over the coming year I will be looking to replace my Audi A3 Sportback 1.4 TFSI which has served me well for 3 years. I particularly like the 1.4 petrol engine which is both smooth and lively so I am looking...
On the 22nd September 2015 I ordered a new Audi A3 Sportback 1.4 TFSI. I was assured by the dealership that the car would arrive either before Christmas or the first week in January. I was told last week...
Related models
More practical version of the A3 has more passenger space and a larger boot. Wide choice of engines including impressive 1.4 TFSI. Well-equipped as standard.

Ask Honest John

Value my car