Where's the best place to fit a space saver?

My mum has just had a flat tyre on the front on her Jaguar X-Type. She called the AA and asked them to fit the space saver spare to the back and fit the back wheel to the front, but he refused.

I am concerned that with all the power and steering going through the front and the massive difference in tyre widths that is is unsafe. I know the speed is only 50 mph with a space saver but even at low speeds it is going to handle very badly. Am I right to be concerned or was the AA guy right?

Asked on 24 March 2014 by Andrew2014

Answered by Honest John
A space saver is only a 'get you home' or 'get you to the tyre dealer' emergency solution. It is not intended to be used on a daily basis. But since it is a restricted speed temporary spare it can go on the front. A warning rarely given is that not only will handling and roadholding suffer, so will braking, particularly on a wet road where the stopping distance could double.
Similar questions
Rather than the 'gunk' kit for punctures I would much prefer a steel spare or space saver wheel. I own a 2008 Ford Fiesta with 195/45/R16s. What are the size options for steel rims?
I can’t see the point of space-saver emergency wheels. A wheel well has to be large enough to take the road wheel when the space-saver is fitted so they do not save space. Also, an alloy road wheel only...
My 2022 Volvo XC40 T3 petrol (not hybrid) did not come with a spacesaver spare wheel, only the gunk and inflator kit, not satisfactory. The 18-inch 5-stud spacesavers for this car are hard to find at breakers....
Related models
Styling has aged well. Good to drive with fine ride and handling.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer