With what could I replace my unreliable 2003 Renault Megane?

I am currently an extremely frustrated driver of a 53-plate 1.5dci Renault Megane. Over the last three months I have shelled out over £1200 pounds to replace the ECU, front coils and top hats and recently the cam belt (after the fan belt shredded and wrapped itself around the cam belt). This has started me thinking about replacing the temperamental Megane. I have a budget of up to £12,000 (but would prefer to spend less than this) and would like a car of a similar size, a diesel engine (due to high commuting mileage) and something with an ounce of reliability. What would you recommend?

Asked on 8 June 2010 by keegs27

Answered by Dan Harrison

Get rid of it asap - that generation of Megane is known to have many, many problems. Many of those are documented here: www.honestjohn.co.uk/carbycar/renault/mk_cit-md_64...d

Any of these hatches would make a fine replacement and will suit your needs: www.honestjohn.co.uk/topten/medium-family

Tags: build quality diesels commuting hatchbacks reliability

Similar questions

Which SUV offers good fuel economy and reliability?

I am a tall 60-year-old man who needs something higher off the ground. I have been looking at SUVs, notably diesels, not necessarily new but as a pensioner I want my cake and to eat it. I'd like something...

Do you recommend the Vauxhall Insignia Estate diesel?

My Jaguar X-Type Estate 2.0D is getting on in years, and I am thinking of changing it for a nearly-new Vauxhall Insignia Estate, probably diesel. Does this car have a good reliability record, and which...

Which is the best fuel-efficient family car?

I need to replace my Volvo S80 and have been looking at the new, very fuel-efficient diesel engine cars (Blue Motion, Greenline, Volvo Drive-e etc). But the problems with DPFs and dual mass flywheels are...

Related models