Which winter wheels should I get for my BMW 1 Series?

I am taking delivery of a new BMW 1 Series later this month. The new car will have 17-inch wheels. I have been enquiring about winter tyres, as you will know that the BMWs are not much good in the snow. The list of tyre sizes and prices I was given are: 16-inch steels with covers £980, 16-inch alloys £1280, or 17-inch alloys £1740, all plus £60 fitting and storage.

I was told that the smaller wheel gives a better grip on the road and does not affect the ride or handling of the car, or the insurance policy. As I am a pensioner a friend said that I should wait and see if there is going to be any snow before I pay out money for the winter tyres.

Asked on 11 March 2012 by NY, via email

Answered by Honest John
Go for the 16-inch steels, and tell your insurance company. The price has gone up. Last year it was £700 and a bargain. The advantage of steels is that alloys can be severely damaged by winter road salt. All that can happen to steels is that they eventually rust a bit under their trims, but that is inconsequential. If you leave it until the country is covered in snow there won’t be any winter tyres left.
Similar questions
I have a 2008 Skoda Octavia Scout, 66,000 miles. It is almost ready for a complete tyre change and I am considering fitting winter tyres until March and then replacing them with a new set of standard tyres....
Can you help please? I know the Ford B-Max is new but I would like to get a set of steel rims and winter tyres for my 1.0 (120) EcoBoost. It has 6.5 x 16-inch offset 40 alloys. I have looked on all of...
We have recently changed from a 4x4 to a Toyota Auris Hybrid and, given your advocacy of winter tyres, are looking to have them fitted. The dealer has recommended Yokohama 215/45 R17 91V, at a cost each...
Related models
A very entertaining car to drive, efficient yet powerful engines, superb infotainment.