Should I buy a Meriva B or Mercedes-Benz B-Class with a push-button handbrake?

I have driven a Vauxhall Meriva since 2005 and have been contemplating a change, perhaps to a Meriva B or possibly a Mercedes B-Class. These both have push button parking brakes. Am I being foolishly old fashioned in my reluctance to go for a car without a conventional lever handbrake?

Asked on 10 June 2012 by CL, Wirral

Answered by Honest John
There is a bit of a rebellion against electric parking brakes. In theory, they clamp brake discs more securely than a lever and cable system ever can, but they can be subject to moisture ingress and can fail. However, all cars must now have dual circuit brakes so if one circuit fails the car will still stop conventionally. I have not heard of complete brake failure for years. For the easiest access, a decent drive and a conventional handbrake, think Ford B-Max.
Similar questions
My Renault Scenic recently had an issue where the handbrake cut in and would not allow the car to move. After contacting the dealer we were told to drive it backwards and forwards, as this would release...
IB of New Milton referred to electric handbrakes. They may be more efficient as a ‘parking brake’ but, at a stroke, car manufacturers are disposing of a vital handbrake function: its use as an ‘emergency...
My recently purchased Peugeot 3008 comes with an electric parking brake as standard. This is the first car I have owned with this type of brake, and I am struggling to master it. With the car on a level...
Related models
Practical and easy to get in and out of. Facelifted 2014 models get impressive new 1.6-litre CDTi engine.
Loads of cabin space front and rear, excellent safety kit, good range of efficient engines, classy image.
Sliding side doors and no central pillar mean unimpeded access. Five star Euro NCAP rating. Engines include 1.0 litre three-cylinder EcoBoost petrol. Decent drive.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer