BMW 328i or Mercedes-Benz E-Class - which should I buy?

I am looking to purchase a new car and, as I only cover about 6000 miles a year, I've shortlisted the BMW 328i and the Mercedes-Benz E-Class Coupe 250CGI, both with automatic gearboxes. I am looking for a degree of comfort and a mix of style, performance and reliability. Which make and model will in your opinion be the best buy?

Asked on 8 November 2012 by DB, Newcastle under Lyme

Answered by Honest John
The F30 BMW 328i. It is an outstanding car, tested here with video: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/bmw/bmw-3-series-f.../
Similar questions
I am thinking of buying a BMW 320d Auto GT M Sport, do these cars have a problem with towing because of the auto gearbox? If they do, does this apply to other auto vehicles as well?
The BMW 3 series has an automatic transmission and a sports automatic transmission on most models. The sports is about £250 extra, not much on the price of the car. Reading the blurb on the BMW website...
You kindly replied to my question regarding choice of BMW 3 series engines, and recommended the 320d ED. Regarding the transmission type, will the manual box eventually succumb to dual mass fly wheel failure,...
Related models
Classy and upmarket coupe. Superb C350 CDI engine. Decent headroom in the back. Good-sized boot. Supportive and comfortable seats.
Brilliant to drive, powerful and fuel-efficient engines, good interior space and practicality.