Can you recommend a workhorse vehicle that will carry five people in comfort, traverse floods and tow a 1.5-ton trailer?

Now that the family have left home my wife and I do almost all our motoring in our MINI Clubman (with which we are well pleased). But I still have our trusty 12-year-old Volvo estate for the relatively infrequent occasions when we need to carry passengers in comfort. I also have a 1989 Land Rover 110 diesel that I use almost exclusively for my (semi-retired self employed) work on the nearby river which is prone to flooding. Both Land Rover and Volvo are getting a bit 'long in the tooth' and as neither of them now covers more than 5,000 miles annually, economics dictate that I replace them with a single vehicle.

Can you suggest something that will cope with multiple short journeys, some of which may be through water up to a couple of feet or so deep, can carry up to five people in comfort OR the tools and equipment of my trade, and will safely tow a trailer of up to 1.5 tons? Budget is not hugely critical but I would prefer to buy something a year or two old. I have been warned off modern Land Rovers due to the vulnerability of their electronics in anything much more than a foot of water; is this right?

Asked on 24 December 2010 by JE, Quorn, Leicestershire

Answered by Honest John
I'd look at a pick up, such as an Isuzu Rodeo 2.5 or 3.0 I-TEQ or maybe a Mitsubishi L200. But if they have diesel particulate filters they won't take kindly to repeated short runs from cold. No diesel with a particulate filter will. And there really aren't many economical 4WD petrol SUVs. The Toyota RAV4 2.0 Valvematic is probably the best.
Similar questions
I currently own a 5-year-old Porsche Boxster and am looking to change it in the next three or four months. I am retired, and enjoy my driving. However, family and bad back considerations suggest a change...
I currently drive a Toyota RAV4 and have been extremely happy with its versatility, reliability and comfort. I need good legroom being 6-feet 3-inches. It has been a great workhorse, helping to move flat...
I am thinking of buying a new or nearly new 4x4 automatic twin-cab pick-up. I have searched the web and reviews for Toyota, Mitsubishi, Isuzu and Mazda are all very similar. My requirement is off-road...
Related models
More practical alternative to the standard MINI. Five useable seats and neat extra rear door to make getting into the back easier. Cooper D is the pick of the range.
Bigger and now 5-door only. More luxurious but not as practical as previous RAV-4. Car-like road manners. Petrol and diesel automatics. Facelifted 2010.
Extremely tough running gear, long tyre life, durable interior, proven four-wheel drive system.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer