Please warn your readers to be careful when making claims from their insurance companies.

Your readers should beware of what has become of a certain big name motor insurer. In my experience they are friendly and helpful when they are taking the money but when you have a claim they will screw you. Having a totally clean record on claims and convictions and a maximum protected NCD, it was my misfortune to suffer two vehicles fires within a year. There was no third party involvement, no negligent driving and, in fact, I was not even within miles of the second incident. My insurer used every trick in the book to avoid meeting the claims, trying to suggest that I had been drinking (an absolute fabrication); failing to maintain the vehicles (also proven to be untrue) and failing to declare that one of the vehicles was dual fuel (untrue).

I was without the vehicles for a total of five months (while they continued to take the premiums on the write-offs). They moved at a snail's pace, never returning my calls, and then finally tried their hardest to reduce the payout by disputing genuine corroborated valuations. They subsequently failed to send me a renewal notice, only producing the details after I contacted them. (This could have left me uninsured had I not been aware of the dates.) The premium had been hiked by 67 per cent and the protection removed from my NCD. When queried they said that despite the protected NCD they had the right to load my premiums anyway, and that I had already been discounted 60 per cent. The old saying; "You are insured until you have a claim" seems so true. I have found cover elsewhere with an increase of only 25 per cent.

Asked on 15 December 2010 by RM, Westmeston, Sussex

Answered by Honest John
Investment Bank and Private Equity Fund investment in car insurance underwriting, car insurance broking, accident management companies and credit hire operators has had the effect of blurring the boundaries. Insurers claim to lose money through the activities of the accident management companies that their policyholders are referred to by their brokers and put up their premiums, yet all the money is going to the same investors. It's a no brainer for them because car insurance is compulsory and there is no regulatory control over levels of premium. The best licence to print money in the UK. Government is either ignoring this scandal or is involved in it.
Similar questions
On your recommendation four years ago I have been a using Insurance4carhire’s global service ever since. This year, for the first time, I had cause to make a claim. My call was dealt with quickly and the...
My insurer of 23 years recently sent me my formal car renewal notice only a few days before it was due, despite my requests a month prior. In that time, they also refused to produce proof of no-claims...
Last December, my son's neighbour reversed into my car, which was parked across the road from him. My car was repaired by the neighbour's insurer after he admitted full responsibility, and I approached...