Why are military personnel penalised on car insurance based on the location of their barracks?

Why don't insurance companies recognise the greater security surrounding cars owned by members of HM Forces living in barracks? I am stationed in one of the less salubrious areas of London, where many of my soldiers, especially the younger ones, are penalised very heavily for the postcode of our barracks. The fact that the vehicles in question are kept behind barbed wire with the protection of armed guards at all times seems to warrant little consideration. I accept that they will pay a higher premium for their profession as, statistically, they represent a higher risk, but the postcode lottery is hard to swallow.

If it were possible to influence insurance companies to recognise 'in barracks' as more secure than in the street, rather than simply apply the crime data for the sink estate next door, you'd have some grateful soldiers in East London. An 18-year-old private does not earn a large wage and is already subject to added premiums for his age and profession. It seems perverse to charge him for the shortfalls of the area in which he is forced to live, when the chances of street crime affecting him outside his 'home' are slim to none. Perhaps profits come first?

Asked on 10 October 2010 by CF, via email

Answered by Honest John
Special cover is now offered at www.24cover.co.uk. Military personnel are regarded as a higher risk, but the policy has a specific advantage of not referencing postcodes (military bases are often in seemingly high risk areas for theft but as the officer said to me "their cars are in a compound surrounded by barbed wire with a chap with a gun on the gate"). Also try: www.towergatewilsons.co.uk/car-insurance.aspx.
Similar questions
My wife recently changed her car from a Land Rover Freelander, worth £2000 and insurance group 23, to a Renault Clio, worth £2000 and insurance group 9. When I changed the vehicle on our Admiral insurance...
When applying for insurance, is it necessary to insure at the address where you will live for a year? Or is it okay to register it at your permanent address where your driving license is registered (parents'...
My daughter has just been told (by a mainstream and well-known insurer) that her premiums have just gone up because an identical car in the same postcode was stolen, therefore the premiums go up. Of course...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer