Should the dealer pay?

I bought a 2005 Saab Vector TiD (c, 43k miles) about a month (and 1,300 miles ago) from a Vauxhall Dealer, he provided a 3 month Dealership Warranty which has a single claim limit of £1,000.

I have taken it to a specialist Saab dealer and the diagnosis is a failed dual mass flywheel - the warranty company have accepted liability and are contributing to the cost of the repair (the total cost is over the single claim limit).

Upon removing the gearbox, The Saab Specialist now sees that the clutch and slave cylinder are both damaged and need replacement (a further £375 - no labour thankfully), the warranty company will not cover these additional repairs.

As both these faults were clearly developing when I bought the car, should the dealer cover the additional repair costs?

Asked on 20 April 2011 by Colin Benson

Similar questions
I think readers should be aware of what I consider to be a very questionable practice by my local Vauxhall dealer. I received a quote of £1310 to replace the DMF which included a new clutch. Warranty...
I run a 2005 Vauxhall Vectra 1.9CDTI 120 as a taxi, purchased new. The dual mass flywheel was replaced under warranty at 42,000 miles, and has just been replaced at 102,000 miles, at £1,000 it is an expensive...
Having given my local Skoda garage £370 to flush contaminated diesel from my Superb estate, a serious cold-start knocking issue persists as bad as ever, disappearing once the engine is just a little warm....
Related models
Decent mix of performance and economy. Superb long-distance comfort aided by good ride and fantastic seats. An exceptionally safe car.
 

Value my car