Is it safe to have tyres with different profiles?

On investigating a slow puncture I noticed that although on my Ford Focus ST has 4 Michelin sports, the front are 205/40 and the rear 205/45. Kwik Fit said they should all be identical but Bristol Street, from whom I bought the car said it was permissible. Who is right? Am I right though in thinking that if I buy two new rear tyres regardless of aspect they should be identical and the same make?

As a single occupant and conservative driver is the load rating discretionary?

One website tells me that speed ratings for replacement tyres must be equal to or higher than the ones supplied new and not discretionary which seems a bit nonsensical as I do not expect to drive at 193 mph, which that website states is for Y.

I also see from the Ford spec on my particular car that the tyres I have 'inherited' are not those stated on the spec. The website I mentioned advises that this can invalidate my insurance? As a matter of interest do MoT inspectors compare each tyre for uniformity as well as wear?

Asked on 12 May 2023 by OGA

Answered by David Ross
There are a lot of separate issues at play here, so we will try to deal with them in turn.

Your front and rear tyres differ in aspect ratio, which is not desirable but neither is it dangerous. It is more important that your tyres are identical across an axle, and in terms of size (unless the manufacturer specification dictates otherwise) rather than the same make, although of course if you have uni-directional tyres then all four should be the same in this respect.

The speed rating of a tyre not only reflects the maximum speed the tyre is safely capable of, but also its capability in respect of the vehicle performance in terms of cornering grip and traction, which is why high performance vehicles frequently have tyres rated higher than their maximum speed. It is not illegal to fit a tyre with a lower speed rating than recommended, but in the event of an accident your insurance company may check the tyre rating and subsequently not pay out on your claim. Ultimately it is your decision if you choose to fit a tyre with a speed rating lower than Y.

As far as the MoT is concerned, testers are required to check that the speed rating is in accordance with the minimum requirements, but this is for the class of vehicle rather than the specific model. However, that does not mean an MoT tester will not fail a car if it has tyres which are substantially below the required speed rating.
Similar questions
Yesterday I fitted four new CrossClimate tyres to my Volkswagen Golf SV. The original tyres were rated at H. The fitter had fitted three H and one V rated tyre. Today, the tyre alarm went off after 30...
I am about to buy new tyres for my car but the one thing I am a little confused about is the end letter H or V etc. It is slightly cheaper by a few pounds to get the H. I don't go over 80 miles an hour...
What are the insurance implications if you change tyres for those with a different speed rating. For example you go for 91H XL tyres instead of 94V or W XL tyres? Many winter tyres appear to come in lower...
Related models
Fitted with impressive 250PS EcoBoost engine. Available as a hatchback or an estate. Great value for money compared to other hot hatches.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer