Back stabber

Someone ran in to the back of my 11 year old Toyota Corolla, and put it ‘beyond economical repair’. I’ve had the car from new in 1998. The insurance company want to offer me book value, but my argument is that as I’m being forced in effect to trade it in, it’s worth £2,000. Any thoughts or suggestions about this please?

Asked on 19 September 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
As long as your insurer does not write the car off and as long as it
remains MoT’d, taxed AND insured, you can trade it in under scrappage. If they write it off and give you a pittance you cannot use the argument you could have traded it in unless you had already done the scrappage deal. Maybe the Financial Ombudsman will make a decision on this to make the situation crystal clear and set a precedent.

Honest John recommends carwow – find and buy your perfect car, in just a few clicks

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
My wife is changing her 1994 Rover 214 for a new KIA Cee'd 1.4 1 hatchback under the scrappage scheme and KIA's very generous contribution. The list price for the KIA is £11,895 and with the allowances...
I am taking advantage of the scrappage scheme to trade in my N reg Peugeot 106 to buy a Hyundai i20 on 1 September. My insurer refuses to amend the value of my Peugeot 106 and says it would (in the event...
Ever since seeing a picture of some 14,000 "scrappage" cars parked on a disused airfield, I have been appalled at the shocking waste of a useful resource this represents, and wondered what, if anything,...

Ask Honest John

Value my car