Volkswagen Golf GTI vs Golf R - which is better?

Which would be most appropriate for everyday use, a second-hand Golf GTI or a used Golf R?

Asked on 17 November 2020 by Robert Tamberlin

Answered by Andrew Brady
Both are fine for everyday use. Our money would go on the GTI - it's got a little less power but is arguably more fun than the Golf R. The Golf R is very good at getting you to your destination quickly, but it's not as involving to drive. Your money will go further on a used GTI, too.
Similar questions
I'm looking at buying a used car to replace my current 1.0-litre runaround as I crave a bit more power. I've been looking at a 1.4 Golf GT TSI, which costs around £2500. I don't have the money yet, but...
It's about time to replace my 2006 Audi A4 2.0 TFSI quattro. I really enjoy driving this car, can you recommend a modern performance saloon replacement? It must be an automatic, petrol, around £20k and...
Any views on the 435d? A 2015 model with less than 15,000 miles can be bought for £25,000 which is only £4000 - 5000 more than the equivalent 420d. The mpg isn't a million miles off the 420d and given...
Related models
Golf GTI performs well in every area, making it the consummate all-round hot hatch.
Surefooted all-wheel drive handling, impressive performance, subtle styling, available as an estate
 

Value my car