Should I get a petrol or diesel SUV?

I'm considering buying a Mercedes-Benz GLB but I'm yet to decide which option is better, the 200 petrol or the 200d diesel one. I'm a normal all-round driver (driving on both motorways and in the city). Although I did test drive the petrol one, I tend to consider the diesel option a better one, both for its higher torque level and its 8-speed gearbox. I'd appreciate any honest advice. Many thanks.

Asked on 14 October 2020 by John Yiannaki

Answered by Andrew Brady
It depends on your mileage, really. If you cover more than 12,000 miles a year including regular motorway trips (say, at least once a week), we'd recommend the 200d. Otherwise, go for the 200 petrol. The diesel might also make sense if you need to tow anything.
Similar questions
I need a new car: large with big boot and good fuel economy for a long commute. Should I get a diesel, petrol, hybrid etc? I would go diesel but I hear people say they are phasing this out. I need a high...
If you were looking for a new or newish SUV with a view to keeping it over ten years, would you still buy a diesel?
My wife and I have a 2015 Ford Kuga, which we are looking to replace it in the not too distant future. We enjoy the ride height and the practicalities of four wheel drive and we do not want an electric...
Related models
Seven-seat SUV to rival BMW X1, Audi Q3 and Range Rover Evoque.

Ask Honest John

Value my car