Snow Tyres vs Insurance

You recommend winter tyres rather than 4wd. At the beginning of last winter I had some snow tyres fitted to my Honda Accord 2.2cdti. They were excellent and in fact managed to get me where 4wd struggled (my daily commute to work includes a hairpin 25% gradient - Sutton Bank in North Yorkshire- and miles of open moorland at the top with drifting snow). However, I had a battle with my insurers as they are classed as a "modification " which needs permission. Simply my car specifies a faster rating than is available in snow tyres and it took many phone calls to my insurers (Churchill) and Honda tech service and various dealers to get the necessary "permission" to fit H rated tyres which were the only ones I could actually get hold of. It wasn't until I hit on a customer service person within Churchill with a bit of common sense that I got permission to fit them. This year I am with Aviva and call centres in India and my initial enquiries have met with the standard "you must fit the specified speed rating" which of course don't come in winter tyres. It's looking like they will not give me permission to fit these winter tyres - so will probably end up in a ditch. Are you aware of this issue with insurers?

Asked on 8 November 2010 by Bonnieballoo

Answered by Honest John
I know Sutton Bank, so that's impressive. Some insurers are completely brain dead about this. If you can't get sense by going higher up the food chain then switch insurers to one with some nous. Obviously they don't have any snow in the South of India anyway.
Similar questions
With regard to fitting winter tyres, would this affect my insurance premium?
I noticed that you have endorsed the use of snow tyres recently. I have been Michelin Alpin, M + S rated tyres in winter since 1997 and swear by them. However, I have seen reports in the press that some...
Please can you remind me the recommeded websites, and the relative advantages of tyre change, or complete wheel change for winter tyres?
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer