Is this poor Fiat Engineering - or just bad luck?

My wife bought a Fiat Panda Cross in Dec 2014 on a PCP. By Aug 2015, the rear differential was leaking oil and needed replacing. Over the period of the three year warranty several other issues came up including the replacement of two ECUs and the reconditioning of the turbo. Now seven months after the warranty has expired and four months before the PCP is paid off, the gearbox has started to grind and shakes. The dealership now thinks the car is worth less than I have left to pay on it and tells me that I will need to pay to have the gearbox investigate or replaced if I want to hand the car back. The car has done less than 58,000 miles. Should I expect a Fiat gearbox to last for longer?

Asked on 27 July 2018 by Tim Hebberd

Answered by Honest John
Tell the dealer and the finance house that you would prefer to settle the matter in the Small Claims track of the County Court. Basically they have sold you a car that has not even lasted the four year repayment period so cannot be considered "of satisfactory quality" under the Sale of Goods Acts. See: www.honestjohn.co.uk/faq/consumer-rights/ Rear diff failure is common on Panda 4x4s. But please tell me if this is a TwinAir or a Multijet diesel.
Similar questions
I bought a brand new Mercedes-Benz GLC Coupe. After 28 days it broke down and had to be recovered. I sent a letter expressing my short-term right to reject the vehicle for not being of satisfactory quality...
I had a new Volkswagen Golf delivered on 11 April with 120 miles on it. Four hours later with 200 miles on it, the car went into limp mode. It was taken to a Volkswagen main dealer and I was supplied with...
I bought a 2014 Audi A3 S-Line from Norwich Audi, they delivered it to me in Coventry, sight unseen and from the day I received the car it had an unusual noise coming from the engine. They directed me...
Related models
Space, practicality and off-road fun in an engaging, affordable package.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer