MG B - Opinions please - Bobbin Threadbare

I've found two MGBs. Opinions please! One is a driver and one is a fixer-upper. The black one looks a pig's-ear TBH.

Red MGB-GT: www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C225817

Black GT: www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C215931

I am sorely tempted and the insurance is really low for someone my age.

MG B - Opinions please - unthrottled

rerd one. The black one wil have a lot of corrosion that is difficult fort a DIYer to deal with. As I suspected, the engine is fine (it's always hot and covered in oil from leaks!) but the body isn't.

MG B - Opinions please - Bobbin Threadbare

Yeah the black one's body condition is tatty!

Just been reading an article about a blind man who fully restored (and I mean from a shell and some bits) an orange one. Thing is, he can't drive it.

MG B - Opinions please - Collos25

The red one is ok if you want to run it for a year and get rid having rebult a B gt from scratch many moons ago these two are both rats requiring new shells and wings and many hours to fetch into pristine condition.If thats your intention spend a bit more and buy one with a newish shell if you just want to run it for a year it does not matter .

MG B - Opinions please - unthrottled

It's the undercarriage that concerns me. Replacing sheet metal panels is cheap 'n' easy. You really need a pit and be handy with a MIG welder to deal with underbody corrosion-way out of the limits of a DIY enthusiast.

MG B - Opinions please - Bobbin Threadbare

The MIG welding I can do but haven't the kit or the pit, alas.

Collos has got a point - maybe I am overeager and should save up some more cash first.

MG B - Opinions please - craig-pd130

B GTs rust badly in several critical areas, you can get all the panels / repair sections easily but it's the time taken to repair it all, and it's always worse than it looks from the outside.

The sills, upper inner wing box-sections and rear spring hangers are all rot-prone. The sills especially are complicated, comprising 4 sections, and on an older car can often need taking right back to the floorpan before being built back up.

I reckon you're better spending more in the first place.

MG B - Opinions please - injection doc

unthrottled and PD130 spot on!

these things seriously corrode in hidden sections called the castle sections and out riggers etc. You need to be prepared to strip well back and lots and lots of welding !

Buy a really nice one or an MX5

MG is slow and thirsty and needs a wet nurse really to look after it>

MG B - Opinions please - Avant

It all depends on what you're looking for, Bobbin.

If you want something fun to drive, save up for a decent MX-5 - which has the advantage of being a convertible and also less prone to rust.

If you're after a classic to restore, and are happy to spend more time welding and tinkering than driving, an MGB is quite a good bet as spares are available and there are owners' clubs. There's a case for buying both these if you can afford it, one as a donor car for spares. I presume that the low insurance quote is for classic car insurance with restricted mileage.

MG B - Opinions please - Bobbin Threadbare

Yeah it was to tinker with. The MX-5 is a given next year (unless someone can persuade me that I would enjoy an Alfa Brera more).

The insurance I looked at through Lancaster classic car insurers and I put basically weekend tootling - the EU ruling levelling off women's and men's insurance will sting if I go with regular insurers!

I had gone with MGB as, like you say Avant, it's reasonably easy to get spares.

I really just wanted other people's opinions on these two to confirm my own suspicions that they're tatty - save myself the petrol of driving out there to look at them!

MG B - Opinions please - unthrottled

'tatty' bodywork isn't the problem-you can practice your sculpting skills with bodywork cement! It's the structural corrosion that's the (hidden) killer. A few pokes under the wheel arches with a screw driver can reveal myriad horrors(although the vender might not be very happy about you doing this ;) )

This was the fate that befell my first car. Nasty MOT man armed with a screwdriver condemned my car-after I'd 'cleverly' hidden all the rust on the sills with Holts underseal paint :)

MGBs are fun cars to drive and work on-but start with one that's structurally sound.

MG B - Opinions please - ohsoslow

I recently thought about getting an MGB, TR6, GT6, or similar when I retire soon in place of my 12 YO MX-5.

My interest is more in the driving pleasures rather than working on the car. On initial searching, a well preserved / restored old British sports car costs as much or more than a very good MX-5 which has much better safety systems etc and after a couple of drives in the classic cars naturally drives a lot better.

So not the way I will go.

I may just stick with my old 5 as it does all I want from a fun car anyway.

A very good Sunbeam Tiger would possibly change my mind but they are rare and would be way too expensive.

MG B - Opinions please - Bobbin Threadbare

The Sunbeam Tiger is lovely! I've never seen one of those before.

MG B - Opinions please - TeeCee

The Sunbeam Tiger is lovely! I've never seen one of those before.

Neither have most people, as there aren't many around for two very good reasons. Firstly the dreaded tinworm. Secondly, long straight sections of road where the stonking straight-line performance may be appreciated have a nasty habit of ending in a bend, where it stops being a Tiger and magically transforms into an Alpine going waaaay too fast.

MG B - Opinions please - ohsoslow

I can believe both points being true. It's just that I often saw one when I was a teenager and loved the shape and sound it made.

That is why I will stick to my 5, not so fast, much better at corners, cheap, easy and fun to own.

MG B - Opinions please - craig-pd130

Heh heh .... true. But the idea of dropping a chunky V8 into a smallish Brit roadster is always fun.

I had an BGT V8 (aftermarket conversion, not a factory job or a Costello) for a couple of years, and it was lovely. Was only a Rover 3500-spec engine on SUs but still gave a useful 50% extra BHP and about 80% more torque than the old B-series (while weighing less), not to mention that exhaust note ....

I made the mistake of having it as my only car, which magnified its faults to the point where they outweighed its qualities :-/

Edited by craig-pd130 on 06/06/2011 at 15:49

MG B - Opinions please - memyself-aye

Beware all rubber bumpered B's - they may look ok but will almost certainly be rotten underneath. Stick your hand through the wheel arch, up and backwards to the flat internal 'trumpet' section under the wing where it meets the screen. If you can then poke your fingers through, it's rotten - and it will be cos they are 30 odd years old now.

Most chrome B's will have either died or (like mine) been restored by now but late original rubber bumpered ones - especially GT's which are not as valuable as roadsters- will still be around and waiting for the unwary.......

MG B - Opinions please - Bobbin Threadbare

Look what I found! www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C189992 £25,500!!

MG B - Opinions please - Big John

I had a Datsun 100A fail on internal bdoywork close to seat belt mount. Tester had pushed a screwdriver through it. I cut out the offending part to discover no rust on either side it was simply thin metal from new!!!

Saying that the rest of the car was rusting, when you turned the engine off you could hear the rust munching through it!

Used to do 50+mpg though.

MG B - Opinions please - Bobbin Threadbare

We had an X-reg Datsun Cherry (is that 1981/2?) when I was a kid; parents got rid of it in about 1990/91. It used to stall for no apparent reason. My dad was awesome with cars but he couldn't fix it! I guess it was an upgrade from an Austin 1100 though!